Skip to content
Malpractice Center

How Common Are Surgical Mistakes?

According to published estimates, US surgical errors reach the thousands each year. You can't tell your particular operation's risk from those estimates.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(4)

Although surgical mistakes are reported regularly, you can't get a reliable overall rate from the firms' published summaries. According to Scott Sonntag's law firm website, there are at least 80 surgical errors each week in the United States. More than 4,000 occur annually, according to a Fuchsberg law firm article. To judge how likely an error is during your own operation, neither number helps.

Counting errors doesn't tell you risk. To calculate risk from a national count of reported or estimated events, you also need the number of operations and a clear definition of what counts as a mistake. You can't make that calculation with the information in either firm's summary.

What the published numbers actually tell us

Surgical-error figures reported by law firm websites
SourceReported figureWhat you can take from it
Scott SonntagAt least 80 surgical errors each week in the USA reported national count, not the percentage of operations involving an error.
Fuchsberg, March 28, 2015More than 4,000 surgical errors per year in the USAn older figure attributed to Medical News Today, not a current annual measurement.

These sources aren't primary. Although the Fuchsberg article credits Medical News Today for its figure, you won't find the underlying study's methods in the firms' summaries. Which events the estimates count isn't explained there, either.

These figures shouldn't be added. Because the firms don't identify separate categories of errors, they haven't established how the figures relate to each other. You shouldn't read either figure as counting every mistake that could happen in an operating room.

The United States is what both estimates cover. If you're asking how often surgical mistakes happen in Canada, these figures can't answer or let you compare the two countries.

Questions about your own case?

Which surgical mistakes do these sources discuss?

According to Scott Sonntag's website, retained surgical sponges are the most common surgical mistake. The firm says so. When you read its summary, you won't find how often sponges are left behind or which mistake categories it compared. You can read about that concern on our retained surgical items page.

Although Fuchsberg's article discusses wrong-site surgery, you shouldn't treat its annual estimate as counting only errors involving the wrong site. More than 4,000 surgical errors generally are described in the summary. Our wrong-site surgery page addresses concerns about where an operation was performed.

Because physician fatigue can affect coordination and judgment, a Miller & Wagner article also identifies it as a cause of mistakes. How often fatigue contributes to surgical errors isn't stated there. To understand what happened during a particular patient's care, you can't rely on that explanation alone.

A national estimate can't explain your surgery

You need to understand what happened in that operating room if you or a family member had an unexpected outcome. That's something a national statistic can't answer. Rather than trying to fit your experience to a headline number, start by looking at the account of your own care.

When you ask the treating team to explain the outcome in plain language, ask whether they believe an error occurred and which part of the medical record backs up their explanation. Ask what they're still uncertain about if their answer isn't clear.

How to organize your questions
  1. Write down the concern

    When you write things down, note what you expected and what happened instead. Record the questions you still need answered, keeping your observations separate from anything someone else told you.

  2. Request the surgical records

    Ask the hospital for relevant medical records, including the operative report. To compare any written explanation you've received with the surgeon's account, keep copies of what you've been given.

  3. Ask for a case-specific review

    Ask a lawyer in your state or province to review your concern if you suspect an avoidable mistake. When you bring your records, point out any that you haven't received yet.

What to do next

Without settling how often surgical errors happen nationwide, you can still ask someone to explain your care. Read the operative report first. Write your concern down, too. A lawyer in your state or province can explain how local rules, including the statute of limitations, apply to you if you're considering a claim. You can visit our US state pages or Canadian province pages.

You're reading general information here, not legal advice. Although a case review can help you ask about your own operation, you can't establish whether you have a malpractice claim from national figures alone.

Common questions

How many surgical errors occur each year?
Crediting Medical News Today for the figure, a March 28, 2015 Fuchsberg article reports that more than 4,000 surgical errors occur annually in the United States. At least 80 occur each week, according to Scott Sonntag's website. You can't use these published estimates as a verified current count or to measure the surgical risk you personally face.
What is the most common surgical mistake?
Although Scott Sonntag's website calls retained surgical sponges the most common surgical mistake, you won't find the underlying categories or a separate sponge count in its summary. Without those details, you're limited in how confidently you can apply that statement across all operations. To identify which errors are most common in Canada, it doesn't help either.
Do these numbers show how risky my operation is?
No. When you look at the reported figures, you won't find the number of operations for comparison or estimates broken down by procedure. A percentage for your surgery can't be calculated from those figures. Instead of relying on a nationwide error count, ask your surgeon about your individual concerns and the operation that's being proposed.
Does a surgical error statistic prove malpractice?
No. To establish what happened during your care or whether it supports a legal claim, a nationwide count won't help. Request your surgical records if you suspect an avoidable mistake, and ask a lawyer in your state or province to explain how the rules apply to you. You're getting general information on this page, not legal advice.

Sources

  1. Surgical errors occur at least 80 times each week in the U.S., Scott Sonntag
  2. Examining Some Common Causes of Wrong-Site Surgery, Fuchsberg
  3. Most Common Surgical Errors, Miller & Wagner

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.