Skip to content
Malpractice Center

What percentage of surgeons get sued?

You can't put one reliable percentage on how often surgeons get sued. What a rate means depends on the surgical field and time period, plus what counts as a lawsuit.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(4)

If you want a clearly defined percentage of surgeons who get sued, there's no reliable one. General surgeons and obstetricians/gynecologists are the most likely to be sued for medical negligence, according to Adler's article, “Which Medical Specialties Have the Most Malpractice Suits?”. You can't use that as a rate for all surgeons. Whether your own surgeon has likely faced a lawsuit is another question it doesn't answer.

What period was counted? Counting surgeons sued within one year tells you something different from counting the lawsuits they've faced over the course of their careers. You can't tell from either percentage alone whether a particular patient received negligent care.

What a surgeon lawsuit percentage needs to tell you

A headline number won't help unless you know what it counts. Does it count each surgeon who's been sued at least once, or count the lawsuits themselves? Which surgical fields are included is worth checking, too. Does the figure cover the United States or Canada when general surgeons are grouped with others?

Different measures answer different questions
MeasureWhat it tells youWhat it doesn't tell you
Surgeons sued during a stated yearThe share facing a lawsuit within that yearThe share sued over an entire career
Surgeons ever suedThe share who have faced a lawsuit by the time measuredHow many lawsuits resulted in payment
Total number of lawsuitsHow many cases were countedThe percentage of surgeons sued
Cases resulting in paymentHow many counted cases produced a payoutThe percentage of surgeons who faced a lawsuit

Those counts aren't interchangeable. If a percentage doesn't name the population or time period, it can sound more useful than it is. When a figure covers general surgeons, it doesn't tell you about every surgical field.

Questions about your own case?

Does getting sued mean a surgeon committed malpractice?

What's counted in lawsuits is allegations. Even when an allegation is counted, that doesn't mean it was found true; payment statistics don't explain what happened during a particular operation.

If your care worries you, begin with what happened to you rather than the lawsuit rate for that surgical field. Write down what you think went wrong, and include the explanation you were given. To review your situation, a lawyer needs those specifics rather than a national percentage.

How often do malpractice lawsuits lead to a payout?

The blog article “How Often Are Medical Malpractice Lawsuits Won?” puts the share of successful medical malpractice lawsuits at 20%; it says 80% end without a payout. That's the blog's claim. What will happen in your case isn't something you can treat those claims as reliably predicting.

That statement doesn't tell you how often lawsuits against surgeons alone succeed. Settlements aren't separated from trial verdicts, and you aren't told which period it counts. If your claim is Canadian, it doesn't give enough detail to apply the figure to it. Until “successful” is defined, you don't know which outcomes you're comparing.

You still don't have an average payout. A percentage tells you how often cases lead to payment, but it doesn't tell you how much gets paid.

What to do if you're concerned about surgery

Your own account comes first. Write down the procedure date and what happened that made you start looking for answers. If you've received an explanation, include it without straying from the facts. Before you decide whether malpractice occurred, you can ask someone to review the care you received.

Gather the records you already have, including any discharge instructions or messages you've received from the surgical team. A lawyer can help you decide which other records to request if you need more, including the operative report. The medical malpractice page gives you a place to start.

Which legal rules apply depends on your state or province. You can start with the US state pages or Canadian province pages, then ask a local lawyer what those rules mean for what happened to you. This page can't give you legal advice, only general information.

When you go to a case review, bring your timeline and the records you have. Ask the lawyer about any filing deadline that affects you, and find out what else they need to review your care before you take the next step.

Common questions

Do neurosurgeons get sued often?
You won't find a clearly defined lawsuit rate for neurosurgeons established in Adler's article. What it says about general surgery can't substitute. The neurosurgery and spine surgery malpractice page gives you somewhere to begin looking for help with that care if you're concerned about brain or spine surgery.
What percentage of plastic surgeons get sued?
You can't get an established percentage for plastic surgeons from either cited article. Using another surgical field's rate won't give you that answer. Write down what happened and the explanation you received if you're concerned about your procedure. To begin seeking a review of your case, you can turn to the plastic surgery malpractice page.
What is the success rate of medical malpractice lawsuits?
The blog “How Often Are Medical Malpractice Lawsuits Won?” gives the success rate as 20%. You can't use that figure to work out your chances of getting paid: the article doesn't say enough about which cases it counted or what it calls “successful,”. Rather than predicting the result with a broad percentage, ask a lawyer to assess what happened in your case.
Is it worth asking a lawyer about a surgical injury?
You don't have to prove malpractice before asking a lawyer to look at an unanswered concern about your surgery. Bring the records you have after preparing a factual timeline. Ask what further information the lawyer needs and how your state or province's rules apply before deciding whether to pursue a claim.

Sources

  1. Which Medical Specialties Have the Most Malpractice Suits?, Adler
  2. How Often Are Medical Malpractice Lawsuits Won?, law-injury.com

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.