What counts as medical malpractice
On this page(8)
Could negligent medical care have caused the harm you're concerned about? That takes more than a poor outcome. A lawyer in your state or province can review the care you're worried about, whether it's your treatment or a family member's, and tell you if the facts support a claim. You don't need to decide whether someone broke the law before a review, so start with the records and dates.
You don't have to decide fault. As you describe the care and what you think went wrong, explain how you're doing now, too. A local review still needs to check which rules apply to you, because this page gives general information rather than legal advice.
1.Something went wrong
Write down dates and names while they're fresh.
2.Get your records
Ask for your full chart and test results.
3.Free case review
A lawyer looks at what happened, free.
4.Medical opinion
A doctor checks whether the care fell short.
5.Start the claim in time
Your lawyer starts the claim before the deadline.
6.Settlement or trial
Many claims settle. Some go to a judge or jury.
What medical malpractice means
A medical condition doesn't itself establish malpractice. To establish malpractice, you'd need to show that a provider's care fell below the applicable standard of care and caused an injury, not just that treatment had a disappointing result.
That isn't easy news. If nobody explained a treatment decision, you may still have questions about it or feel you weren't heard. You deserve a clear explanation of what happened, though those concerns aren't enough on their own to establish a malpractice claim.
The questions a case review needs to address
- Standard of care: Ask what care the provider should have given in the circumstances you're describing during the review. How would the lawyer assess that care under your jurisdiction's rules?
- The alleged departure: Point to the decision or action you're concerned about. Instead of saying the care felt poor, describe exactly what happened (they aren't the same).
- Causation: Describe how you think the suspected mistake caused the injury. Ask how to show that the mistake caused the injury, paying attention to when things happened.
- Harm: Describe what's changed for you or your family. When you describe what you've experienced, distinguish it from what you think caused it.
An anonymous discussion on r/paralegal shows that explaining causation during malpractice intake can be hard. It isn't an authority. You'll still need to explain how negligent care caused the harm, even if the outcome was bad.
How to describe the suspected error
Name the moment during care that worries you. You might still need an explanation of a treatment decision or of something that happened while you were receiving care. Everyday words work. A convincing-sounding medical term won't fill a gap in your memory, so don't use it that way.
Don't treat conclusions as observations. The reviewer needs to examine “That decision caused the injury” as a conclusion, rather than a memory such as “I asked about this during the appointment”. Are you remembering something or drawing conclusions?
No single medical warning sign on this page can tell you that malpractice occurred. Don't wait for a legal review if your health worries you now: seek medical attention, and prepare for the case discussion by noting when you noticed the problem and what you told the care team.
Birth Injury and Obstetrical Malpractice cover concerns you may have about delivery care. The Anesthesia Errors page is another place to read about that care. Your family can also read the hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) page when researching that diagnosis. Reading that title doesn't establish malpractice.
The records matter more than the volume
Start with records you already have. A reviewer needs to know which statements are yours, so keep your own account separate from the chart. Note anything you think is missing so you can ask the lawyer which other records you should request.
- File boxes of medical records described by one anonymous Reddit commenter about a single case review. This is an anecdote, not a typical case size.
- 17
- Source
Your account alone won't tell you how many records the case will need. Having a thick stack doesn't prove negligence. Ask which records the reviewer needs first, then include a short timeline so they don't have to hunt through paperwork to understand your concern.
Write a dated account
Identify the care you're questioning. Write down the dates you know, making clear where you've had to give an approximate date. Include when you first became concerned.
Identify the people and facilities
Use the names in your records to list the providers who were involved. Don't assign responsibility if you don't know who made a decision; say you don't know.
Describe the effects
Describe what's different since the event, including how it's affecting you now. Don't guess at a diagnosis or predict how you'll recover.
Gather what you have
Save copies of your chart along with any communications you've already kept. Have the lawyer tell you which other records would help them evaluate the suspected error.
Ask about the filing clock
Talk to the lawyer about the dates early in your conversation. Before you file a complaint, ask the lawyer which deadline applies and whether you have to do anything first.
Deadlines depend on where the care occurred
Medical malpractice filing deadlines depend on your state or province. You still need to check your own deadline, even if you've contacted a law firm or heard about someone else's. Bring the dates to a lawyer who handles claims in that jurisdiction so they can explain which filing rules apply.
To read about where you received care, start with the state pages or Canada pages. There's no universal statute of limitations on this page, which also doesn't give deadlines for individual states or provinces.
Compensation and damage caps need a local answer
These law-firm listings don't give us enough to quote an average malpractice payout. An offer to discuss compensation at a consultation isn't payment data, so you can't use a listing to judge what your own claim might be worth.
Ask whether a damage cap in your state or province applies to your claim, then have the lawyer explain what that would mean for you. Start by explaining the injury and its effects before talking about a possible amount. Keep the bills or other documents you'd like the lawyer to consider in the review.
These listings don't document the results of the firms' cases. Ask what's behind any estimate a lawyer gives you, because agreeing to a consultation doesn't tell you what you might recover.
Choosing a lawyer for a malpractice review
Check that the attorney handles medical malpractice claims in the state or province relevant to yours. Ask about cases involving the care you're questioning and who would review your records, rather than hiring by a listing's city name (it's just a starting point).
Morgan & Morgan's Colorado listing offers a free case evaluation if you suspect medical negligence. The San Antonio listing for Bailey & Galyen offers a private consultation too, but an invitation to contact either firm only tells you they're open to inquiries, not whether they're right for your case.
- What does the attorney need from you before deciding whether to take your case?
- Ask the attorney to explain fees and case expenses before you agree to representation.
- Ask how you'll get updates, including who will be contacting you.
- Ask what's still unclear after the first review, especially whether the suspected error caused your injury.
Be frank with the lawyer. Include any different explanation another provider gave you when you tell the lawyer what happened, even if some facts don't support your concern. You don't have to argue your case when no one has even examined the chart yet.
What to do next
Contact a lawyer in your state or province after you've written a short account of the event and gathered the documents you already have, and ask about timing first. You can ask for a review without knowing for sure what happened.
Common questions
Who are some good medical malpractice lawyers in South Carolina?
Do you go to jail for medical malpractice?
What should I avoid withholding from a medical malpractice attorney?
What is the average payout for malpractice?
How hard is it to win a medical malpractice case?
Sources
- Medical malpractice intakes discussion, Reddit, r/paralegal
- Medical Malpractice Claim in Colorado, Morgan & Morgan
- San Antonio Medical Malpractice Lawyers, Bailey & Galyen











