On this page(6)
If negligent care caused nerve damage after surgery, you may be able to sue for it. Having an injury doesn't establish malpractice. Even if you were worse off after the operation, the question is whether the care fell below the standard of care and whether that failure caused your harm.
When you're in pain or worried about recovery, that can be hard to hear. You don't have to figure out whether someone made a preventable mistake without help. If you speak with a lawyer in your state or province, they can explain which rules apply to what happened to you.
When nerve damage may support a malpractice claim
Although every surgery carries risks, Justice For Patients explains that a nerve injury caused by a preventable error or negligence may support a medical malpractice claim. An injury can happen even with appropriate care, so it's important to distinguish that from an injury caused by care that should have been different.
You'll find the same distinction in an Avvo legal answer about pain and a bad surgical outcome. Unless a doctor violated the standard of care, a bad outcome alone isn't enough to establish malpractice.
| What you know | What remains to be examined |
|---|---|
| You have nerve damage after surgery. | Whether negligent care caused it. |
| The surgery didn't give you the result you hoped for. | Whether the doctor violated the standard of care. |
| You believe the hospital was responsible. | Whether the hospital's negligence caused your injury. |
Begin with what happened, and when you talk to a lawyer, distinguish what you've experienced from what a clinician has diagnosed. For example, describe the pain using your own words. If anyone has identified nerve damage, explain that and what they said caused it.
Can you sue the hospital?
Maybe. To bring a claim against the hospital, you must prove its negligence caused the injury, according to the law firm's page “Can I Sue Hospital for Nerve Damage?”. Even if your surgery happened there, that fact alone doesn't tell you whether the hospital caused the injury.
To find out who may be responsible, ask a lawyer. Just because the operation took place at that hospital, don't assume it's the defendant to choose. When you speak with the lawyer, give them the hospital's name and the surgeon's name, along with any explanation you've received about the injury. If you don't know who handled a particular part of your care, it's fine to say so.
Prepare a clear account for a case review
Your first account can be simple: write down why you had surgery and what you were experiencing before it. Follow that with what changed afterward. If you know the dates, include them; label any date you're estimating as an estimate.
For the consultation, gather any surgical records or follow-up notes and keep them together. If more records are needed, the lawyer can tell you which to request. Just because the medical language is unfamiliar, you don't need to translate it into a conclusion about who was at fault.
When you describe the injury, explain how it affects daily life. If you can no longer do something or it now takes more effort, give your own examples. Even so, those observations don't mean you're saying the injury is permanent. Unless a clinician has told you it's permanent, keep that question separate from what you've observed.
Keep recovery questions separate from legal questions
Even if you may have a claim, that doesn't tell you how long recovery will take. When you speak with your treating clinician, ask what they believe is injured and what follow-up they recommend. Find out which changes you should report, too. Rather than relying on another patient's recovery story, seek guidance about your own operation if you have nerve pain after ankle surgery or concerns about a foot injury.
If you're considering a claim, a lawyer can assess it. But if you're asking about treatment or whether your nerve damage is permanent, speak with a clinician who can evaluate you.
Ask about the filing deadline early
Which rules apply depends on your state or province. When you talk to a local lawyer, ask which statute of limitations applies and which dates matter in your situation. Someone else's case isn't a guide to choosing your filing deadline. For a starting point, visit the US state pages or Canadian province pages.
What to do next
Ask for a case review, and bring your account of the surgery along with whatever records you already have. During the review, ask what needs to be examined to tell a surgical risk apart from negligent care. If you're a US reader, the nerve damage page offers a place to start. Because this is general information rather than legal advice, you'll need a lawyer in your state or province to assess your circumstances.
Common questions
Is nerve damage after surgery automatically malpractice?
How can I tell whether my nerve damage is permanent?
What should I ask a lawyer before pursuing a claim?
Sources
- Surgical Nerve Damage, Justice For Patients
- Can I Sue Hospital for Nerve Damage?, BLGWins.com
- Will I be able to sue for pain, suffering and bad surgery?, Avvo


