Skip to content
Malpractice Center

Is it worth suing a doctor for malpractice?

If you're considering a claim, weigh your injury and what the evidence supports against what pursuing it would cost. Get a case review before asking about settlement amounts.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(6)

If your injury seriously affects your life, a malpractice lawsuit may be worth pursuing when the evidence supports a claim against the doctor. For now, you don't have to choose a lawsuit. Ask a lawyer in your state or province to review what happened, then explain whether bringing a case would make financial sense.

For now, not every question needs an answer. When you first talk, ask the lawyer what happened during your care and how that differs from what a lawsuit could realistically address.

Start with the injury and the evidence

According to Morgan & Morgan's guide to suing a doctor for negligence, a case's value depends partly on injury severity and long-term impact. It also depends on the evidence's strength. Before looking at the dollar amount in someone else's case, start with those factors.

What's changed in your life because of the injury? When you talk to the lawyer, explain whether you can work as before and what care you need now. If you're asking for a family member, don't stop at the diagnosis; describe how life has changed for them since the injury.

To address what caused the injury, ask the lawyer to assess the care. Even if you're certain something went wrong, the lawyer reviewing your case needs to check what the records support. What else needs investigating? Ask.

Ask whether the case makes financial sense

Even if you have a possible claim, pursuing a lawsuit may not be worthwhile. Ask how the firm would weigh the potential recovery against the cost of bringing the case before you agree to have it represent you.

Make sure the fee terms are written down. If you pay for an initial consultation, those payment terms may not match the terms for reviewing records or filing a lawsuit. They aren't necessarily the same.

  • For that initial review, what would I pay?
  • Besides the lawyer's fee, how would you calculate any expenses I might be charged and that fee?
  • While the case is underway, who pays those expenses?
  • What would I owe if the case doesn't produce a recovery?

If the terms aren't clear to you, ask the firm to explain them. Before you receive any money from a possible settlement it mentions, what deductions could come out? Ask what assumptions went into that estimate.

Questions about your own case?

Consider the personal cost, too

You don't have to let money decide this. When you explain what you hope to achieve, ask the lawyer whether a lawsuit could help you get there.

Tell the firm plainly what you can manage. Ask what work the firm would need from you if you're recovering from treatment or caring for someone else, and how you'd hear about what's happening. Before assuming the lawyer can do everything without your help, ask how much work you'd likely have.

Ask the lawyer about your other options if you aren't ready to pursue litigation. Before choosing what to do, also find out whether waiting or taking another route could affect the claim you might have.

Use a case review to answer these questions

Prepare for the first conversation
  1. Write down what happened

    When you write a short account, describe the care that concerns you and the injury that followed. If you're unsure about something, mark it, and keep what you remember separate from what the chart says.

  2. Ask which records the lawyer needs

    Which documents do you have? Let the firm know. Does it need your chart or discharge paperwork before it can meaningfully assess your case? Find out whether it needs other records.

  3. Request an explanation of the weak points

    When you ask what supports your claim, also ask what could make pursuing it difficult. Before the firm decides whether to take your case, what further review would it need? Ask about that next.

  4. Check costs and timing

    When you request the proposed fee agreement, also ask whether any deadline may apply. Before taking your next step, ask the lawyer how your state or province's rules affect it.

Don't base the decision on an average payout

There needs to be a basis for a settlement estimate. If the lawyer suggests an amount, ask how your injury and the available evidence support it. Before accepting a headline figure, make sure you understand the reasoning behind it.

According to Morris James, medical malpractice claims are legally and technically complex; it warns against handling even low-value legal claims yourself. That warning gives you a reason to seek legal help assessing a claim, but it doesn't measure your chances. You can't use it to gauge what your case might pay.

What to do next

Arrange to have your case reviewed. When you go, bring your questions about the injury and the records you already have; remember that rules differ by state or province. Before asking a local lawyer how those rules apply to you, start with the US state pages or Canadian province pages.

You're reading general information here, not legal advice. Ask the firm to explain plainly why it would pursue your case before you commit to a lawsuit. What would you agree to pay? Ask.

Common questions

Is it hard to win a malpractice lawsuit?
Although Morris James describes malpractice claims as legally and technically complex, that description doesn't show how likely your own case is to succeed. When a lawyer reviews the records, ask what they support and where your case may be weak. Find out what further review is needed before deciding whether to pursue the case.
What is the average medical malpractice settlement?
You can't predict your case's value from an average. According to Morgan & Morgan, that value depends on injury severity and long-term impact, as well as how strong the evidence is. Instead of relying on an average, ask a lawyer to assess your circumstances and explain what fees and expenses could mean for any recovery.
Should I sue if my main goal is an explanation?
If you mainly want an explanation, tell the lawyer before you start discussing a lawsuit. What could litigation address? Ask. You may have other options, too; not every concern has to become a demand for money. When the lawyer proposes legal action, ask how it fits what you want to get from it.
Can I handle a medical malpractice claim myself?
According to Morris James, malpractice claims are legally and technically complex; it warns against handling even low-value legal claims yourself. Before trying to proceed alone, have a lawyer in your state or province look at your case and assess it. When you discuss the cost of representation, also ask how much work the firm would need from you.

Sources

  1. Can You Sue a Doctor for Negligence? Everything You Need to Know About Medical Malpractice, Morgan & Morgan
  2. The Dos and Don'ts of Medical Malpractice, Morris James

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.