Skip to content
Malpractice Center

Can You Sue a Doctor for a Mistake During Surgery?

If a surgical mistake fell below the standard of care and caused harm, you may have a claim. You can't tell from a bad outcome alone.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(6)

If a doctor made a surgical mistake, you may be able to sue. To do that, you'd need to show that the doctor fell below the applicable standard of care and caused you harm. That's the distinction The Jewkes Firm describes. You can't establish negligence from an unexpected complication alone.

Explain what happened first. If your operation worries you, ask the treating team what caused the complication and what care you need right now. Before deciding whether what happened was malpractice, you can ask for a medical explanation that's clearer.

When does a surgical mistake become malpractice?

For a legal claim, you'd need to show that the doctor failed to provide the required care and thereby caused an injury. When a surgeon breaches the standard of care, Cohen & Jaffe explains, the surgeon may be liable for medical negligence.

They're two different questions. Even when you know something went wrong, you don't know from that alone whether the surgeon's care fell below the standard. You may suspect the surgeon made a mistake but still not know if it caused your current problems.

The lawyer reviewing your case needs to hear what you think the doctor did wrong and what changed afterward. You don't have to know that. You don't need to settle the legal question yourself; tell the lawyer what happened to you and how it felt.

A complication isn't automatically proof of negligence

As Mellino Law acknowledges, a skilled surgeon can still face complications during surgery. A bad outcome by itself doesn't tell you whether the doctor's care was negligent.

The word “complication” still doesn't explain what happened. Your doctor can explain why the complication happened during the procedure, so ask about it. If you're still unsure after talking with your doctor, a lawyer who handles medical malpractice claims can hear what's worrying you about the surgery.

When you take notes, keep that difference clear. To record what you were told, write “The doctor told me this was a complication”; “The doctor admitted negligence” means something different. Try to use their actual words in your notes. Say when you're writing from memory.

Questions about your own case?

Prepare for a surgical malpractice case review

You don't have to identify an error to ask. A short account of your operation will help you explain what's worrying you. Say what it's doing to you now, too. The steps below can help keep your conversation focused.

What to prepare before contacting a lawyer
  1. Write down the sequence

    Write down the surgery date along with what you were told before the operation and afterward. Keep what you saw yourself separate from anything a doctor or family member told you about the surgery.

  2. Gather the documents you already have

    Your discharge instructions belong with the other paperwork from your surgery. Ask the lawyer which medical records you'll need before you request them, including whether the operative report would help with reviewing what happened.

  3. Describe the effects in concrete terms

    How are you doing now? Be specific about whether you've needed additional treatment or missed work; “the surgery went badly” doesn't tell the lawyer that.

  4. Bring the unanswered questions

    When discussing the suspected error, ask whether it could fall below the standard of care and explain your injury. Before the lawyer can assess the claim, what else do they need? Ask about that, too.

Does the claim have to be against the surgeon?

Not automatically. According to Mellino Law, any type of medical provider could potentially face a negligence lawsuit. You shouldn't take that to mean a lawsuit should name everyone involved in your operation.

Tell the lawyer whose conduct concerns you, if you know. If you don't know who made the decision, describe what happened instead. Rather than guessing at a name, don't assume someone was responsible just because they were the person who spoke with you afterward.

Get advice where the surgery happened

Your state or province has its own claim rules. To understand what those rules mean for your surgery and when you'd need to file, speak with a lawyer in the relevant jurisdiction. If you found a deadline for another location, don't rely on it.

To find the right location, start with the US state pages or Canadian province pages. You can also visit the medical malpractice page if you're in the US.

What to do next

Bring whatever paperwork you have, along with your short account, to the lawyer reviewing your case. The complication alone isn't enough for a prediction; ask the lawyer to look at the suspected error and whether it caused your injury. This is general information, not legal advice for you.

Common questions

Can I sue if my surgery had an unexpected complication?
Maybe. An unexpected complication isn't enough to establish negligence; you'd need to show that the doctor's conduct fell below the applicable standard of care and caused harm. Your treating team can explain the complication, so ask. If you're still worried after that explanation, a lawyer in the state or province where you had surgery can discuss your concerns.
What should I tell a malpractice lawyer first?
Start with the operation you had and its date. The lawyer also needs to hear how the problem you're describing is affecting you now. Say you're unsure if you don't know whether anyone made a mistake. After bringing the surgery-related paperwork you already have, ask the lawyer what other records they'd like to see before reviewing your claim.
What are my chances of winning a surgical negligence claim?
You can't put a reliable percentage on your chances of winning just because something went wrong during surgery. Before assessing your claim, a lawyer needs to look at the alleged failure in care and whether it caused your injury. Ask what information is still missing before you expect the lawyer to assess where your claim is strong or weak.
How can I raise safety concerns before surgery?
To confirm your surgeon knows who you are and which surgery is being performed, follow the recommendation from KJT Law Group. During that conversation, speak up if you're uncertain about the procedure that's planned for you. While this can help you prepare, it doesn't promise that your surgery will happen without an error.

Sources

  1. Can I Sue for Medical Negligence?, The Jewkes Firm
  2. When Can You Sue for Surgical Complications?, Cohen & Jaffe
  3. Can I Sue My Doctor for Medical Negligence?, Mellino Law
  4. Guide to Protecting Yourself From Surgical Negligence, KJT Law Group

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.