About birth injury claims
On this page(9)
If a preventable error harmed your baby during pregnancy, labor or delivery, you may have grounds for a medical malpractice claim. An injury isn't proof of negligence. To assess a claim, a lawyer in your state or province can examine the care against the required standard. They'll also consider whether any failure caused the harm.
First, address your child's medical needs. You can request the records if you're also worried about the delivery, then ask for a legal review. The diagnosis alone can't tell you who's responsible for the injury.
1.Something went wrong
Write down dates and names while they're fresh.
2.Get your records
Ask for your full chart and test results.
3.Free case review
A lawyer looks at what happened, free.
4.Medical opinion
A doctor checks whether the care fell short.
5.Start the claim in time
Your lawyer starts the claim before the deadline.
6.Settlement or trial
Many claims settle. Some go to a judge or jury.
What a birth injury means
Harm to a baby associated with pregnancy, labor or delivery is called a birth injury. Too little oxygen reaching the brain can cause harm, as can physical trauma during birth. For a malpractice claim, the review must determine whether a medical error caused an injury that appropriate care could have prevented.
That distinction matters. After a difficult delivery, you may still have unanswered questions, particularly if a serious diagnosis follows. You can't establish negligent care from a difficult delivery or a serious diagnosis alone.
The Janda Law Firm's birth injury page separates injuries associated with medical care from birth defects that may arise through genetics or fetal development. The page also discusses pregnancy claims that may involve medication. You can't determine the cause from the diagnosis label alone.
How preventable injuries can happen
Failures to monitor maternal and fetal health appear on Katz Personal Injury Lawyers' birth injury page, alongside delays in performing a needed C-section. Improper use of forceps or vacuum extractors is another possible source of injury it identifies.
Missed signs of distress or delayed delivery
A problem needing a response may show up during monitoring. Fetal heart monitoring and acidic blood can provide information relevant to oxygen deprivation or fetal distress, Katz's page explains. The page also identifies fetal bleeding and placental complications as circumstances that may require a C-section.
Timing needs close review. What the care team knew, and when it acted, needs a lawyer's examination. A delay alone isn't enough legally. The team must have missed a required response, with that failure causing harm.
Physical trauma during delivery
Katz's page explains that nerves stretched or torn by shoulder trauma can leave an arm or hand paralyzed. It also describes how improper forceps use can press on the facial nerve and cause facial paralysis.
An instrument's use alone doesn't explain everything. How the instrument was used needs review. The circumstances also matter in assessing whether the injury could have been avoided.
Problems during pregnancy
Labor isn't always the starting point. Katz's page discusses monitoring for gestational diabetes and recognizing potential complications, including an unusually large baby or a prolonged pregnancy. Janda's page also discusses allegations involving a patient's chart left unreviewed or a failure to warn about a medication's effects during pregnancy.
Care before delivery can be part of the review, too. Earlier pregnancy concerns are worth discussing with the lawyer, along with whether to examine the prenatal chart.
Warning signs and injuries to discuss with the care team
Warning signs in labor aren't the same as diagnoses afterward. A later diagnosis describes your child's condition. Fetal distress, by contrast, may signal a problem as it develops. Ask your treating clinician whether the two are connected. Neither one, alone, is proof of malpractice.
- Ask what appeared on the fetal monitoring and whether the team identified distress.
- Ask what prompted the decision to deliver if there was a delay in the C-section. Ask for an explanation of the timing.
- If your baby's arm or hand is paralyzed, ask whether shoulder trauma damaged the nerves and whether that's part of the diagnosis.
- After an instrument-assisted delivery, ask the clinician what they believe caused any facial paralysis.
- For a brain injury diagnosis, you can ask what's known about any oxygen deprivation. Find out what's still uncertain, too.
Collarbone fracture also appears on Katz's page, along with complications from aspiration of meconium (material from a fetal bowel movement). Ask for a medical explanation of these conditions. You can't use these conditions as a checklist to decide whether to sue.
What makes an injury medical malpractice
For a malpractice claim, the review must link care to harm. Your child's current treatment needs don't establish a claim. A frightening birth, on its own, isn't enough either. A lawyer in your province or state can explain which legal requirements apply to your family.
| Issue | Question for the review |
|---|---|
| Standard of care | What care was required under the circumstances, and did the provider fall below that standard? |
| Causation | Did the failure cause the child's injury, rather than merely occur during the same delivery? |
| Harm | What injury and resulting treatment needs can be connected to that failure? |
The delivery time alone won't establish an allegation that a C-section was delayed. Was earlier delivery required? The review must answer that question, then examine whether the delay caused the claimed injury. Medical expert testimony may be needed to explain that connection. Katz's page describes the role of that testimony in birth injury lawsuits.
Responsibility may extend beyond the obstetrician who provided care. Nurses' and anesthesia providers' errors also appear on Katz's page. The hospital may bear responsibility for employee negligence or inadequate procedures, the page also explains. Rather than assuming one person caused everything, ask the lawyer whose conduct the records support examining.
What to do next
Get an explanation of the diagnosis
A written diagnosis can help you keep track. Ask your child's clinician for one and an explanation of the suspected cause. The cause may remain uncertain. Find out what information could clarify the cause. Keep the clinician's explanation with your child's care paperwork.
Request the records
Ask for copies of the prenatal chart and delivery notes. To examine monitoring and the delivery decision, the lawyer may need more records. Ask which ones would also help explain your baby's condition afterward. Save a copy of each record you receive.
Write down your recollection
Record your memories of concerns raised during pregnancy or labor. Include who spoke with you and what you recall them saying about delivery. Don't fill in gaps. Flag details you don't remember clearly.
Ask a local lawyer about timing
The lawyer will need the care dates and the date of any later diagnosis. Have the lawyer explain the applicable statute of limitations, including whether other filing requirements affect the claim. A deadline in an online discussion isn't something you should rely on.
Discuss the medical review
Have the lawyer explain the review: how they'll compare the care with the required standard and investigate the injury's cause. Katz's page notes that birth injury cases may need expert witnesses. Find out which records the lawyer wants before you decide whether to proceed.
You don't need a finished theory of negligence. Bring your unresolved questions to the lawyer, including anything that remains unclear after the hospital's explanation.
Deadlines differ by state and province
There's no single US or Canada filing deadline that applies to all birth injury claims. Your state or province has its own statute of limitations. A lawyer where you received care can explain the rules, including how they apply to your circumstances.
Start with the state pages or the Canada pages to find local information. Check the deadline early on. A clearer medical explanation can wait; asking about the deadline doesn't have to.
Choosing a lawyer for a birth injury review
You can ask for a plain explanation of the lawyer's approach to birth injury claims. Who will review the records? Ask that, along with how the firm handles medical expert testimony. While that review is underway, you'll also want to know who's responsible for answering your questions.
- Robert N. Katz's stated history of helping families after birth injuries, as reported on the firm's birth injury page
- Over 25 years
- Source
Your result can't be predicted from years in practice. Has the lawyer handled claims involving the suspected error in your child's care? Ask about that experience. Ask how they'd investigate the suspected error in your case.
Talk about payment before you agree to representation. Janda's Nevada page says it accepts birth injury cases on a contingency fee basis. Katz's Georgia page offers a free consultation, the firm says. It also states that a fee is charged only if the firm achieves a recovery. The firms state those payment terms. Other lawyers may offer different terms.
Request the proposed agreement, then ask the lawyer to explain the fees and case costs. If the medical review doesn't support a claim, you'll want to know what happens next.
Getting answers without assuming an outcome
A birth injury can cause serious harm that lasts. Lifelong disabilities appear on Katz's page, along with the cost of future medical treatment. Whether your family can recover compensation depends on the claim and the applicable rules.
The chart is a starting point you can check. So are the reasons behind the delivery decisions. Write down your questions so you can discuss them with a clinician or lawyer.
This page offers general information, not legal advice. Ask a local lawyer how the law applies to your family. For questions about the diagnosis and care, speak with your child's treating clinician.
Common questions
Is cerebral palsy a birth injury?
What are the different classifications of birth injuries?
How can birth injuries be avoided?
What is the most common birth injury?
What is the worst tear in childbirth?
Sources
- Atlanta Birth Injury Lawyer, Katz Personal Injury Lawyers
- Las Vegas, Nevada Birth Injury Lawyer, The Janda Law Firm
- Illinois Birth Injury Lawyer, The Collins Law Firm











