Among the firms we reviewed, Potestio Law stands out because it dates to 1986 and clients describe feeling supported. Check whether the firm handles your kind of medical injury before you call. Ask how the fees work and who would review your records. You can check filing rules in the Ontario law guide.
Lawyer: Jeremy Syrtash, Head of Medical Malpractice Litigation
Jeremy Syrtash leads the medical malpractice litigation practice at Diamond & Diamond Lawyers LLP. He earned a BA from Yeshiva University (2010) and a JD from the University of Ottawa (2013), was called to the Bar of Ontario in 2014, and has acted as counsel and co-counsel in medical malpractice cases across Canada, many involving pediatric and obstetrical negligence.
Called to the Bar of Ontario, 2014 · JD, University of Ottawa · Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Canada, Health Care Law (2024 to 2027)
Best for: Clients seeking established local counsel
Since 1986, Potestio Law has practised law. Tony Potestio and Alia Khan are among its lawyers, as is Monica Zakhari. Along with its Thunder Bay office, the firm has offices in Toronto and Vaughan.
Stood out in our review for its years of experience.
We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made
Best for: Medical malpractice and insurance disputes
Medical Malpractice appears expressly among ERICKSONS LLP's practice areas, alongside insurance law and civil litigation. That makes it a firm to ask directly about a claim involving a health care provider. Established in 1986, it has an office in Thunder Bay and additional offices in Geraldton, Manitouwadge, Marathon and Terrace Bay.
Stood out in our review for its years of experience.
We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made
Not sure who to call first?
Tell us what happened. A malpractice lawyer who serves Thunder Bay can look at it with you, and it costs nothing.
If your family wants to communicate in English or French, de Bakker Law lists both languages. Medical Malpractice is part of its Thunder Bay practice, alongside civil litigation. Other matters it handles include real estate and criminal law.
We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made
When you tell the lawyer what happened, explain when you learned the care may have caused harm. If your claim involves a child, they can assess whether that affects Ontario's 2-year discovery period and 15-year ultimate period as they apply to you.
Review the medical care
When the lawyer assesses the care and its connection to the injury, your medical records help. Before medical opinions are obtained, ask how that would happen and who would pay. Whether the provider met the standard of care isn't clear from a poor outcome alone.
Start the claim
Before the applicable limitation period ends, you must start the claim. To start it in Ontario, you don't need an affidavit or certificate of merit. Ask your lawyer what belongs in the statement of claim, which is the document setting out the allegations.
Serve expert reports
The court's rules require, in practice, that expert reports on the standard of care and causation be served. Those reports address whether the alleged failing caused the injury, as well as what care the provider was expected to give.
Assess the losses and possible resolution
When assessing a claim's value, the losses claimed matter, as do the medical findings. Economic losses such as future care aren't subject to a statutory cap in Ontario. For non-pecuniary damages, which compensate for losses such as pain and suffering, a judge-made national cap sets a limit.
Malpractice claims in Thunder Bay: the rules that matter
The filing deadline in Ontario
The clock startsWhen you found out, or should have
Time to start a claim2 yearsMiss it and the claim is usually lost.
At the very most15 yearsafter the treatment, with a few exceptions
Limits on damages in Ontario
Pain and sufferingCapped at about $484,330
All damages togetherNo overall cap
Expert paperworkNo affidavit or certificate of merit is required to start a claim.
A written agreementThe share the lawyer takes, set out before work starts.
If you recover moneyThe agreed share and the case costs come out of it.
If the claim failsNo legal fee on a contingency agreement. Ask about costs.
According to Potestio Law, it works on contingency. If the claim fails, there's no lawyer's fee; otherwise, the fee is a share of what's recovered. We haven't confirmed how ERICKSONS LLP and de Bakker Law arrange their fees. Case costs aren't those fees. Medical records and medical opinions have costs, and court fees are part of those expenses too. If the firm advances those costs rather than expecting you to pay as they arise, who bears them if the claim fails? Before you sign, get the fee calculation in writing, including who's responsible for costs. Even with a free consultation, the whole case isn't free.
Among the listed firms, Potestio Law says you can get a free consultation and arrange to pay contingency fees.
What to bring to your first call
A short timeline you've written about the treatment and what happened afterward
When treatment happened, along with when you first suspected it caused harm
Who the health care providers involved were, by name
Medical records already in your hands, with delivery notes if they're relevant
Letters or messages you've received from the hospital or insurer
Details of lost income or care expenses, together with bills
If relevant, photos of visible injuries
How old your child is, plus details about a litigation guardian if applicable
Questions to ask a lawyer
1Has your work included claims about care like mine?
2Who would handle my file, including reading my medical records?
3Given my situation, how would Ontario's limitation periods apply?
4To assess my claim, which medical opinions would you need?
5If you offer a free first consultation, what does it cover?
6Who pays case costs, and how is your fee calculated?
7If the claim fails, what might I owe?
8How will you keep me informed, including whom I should contact for updates?
Choose a lawyer for the medical issue
Begin by describing the care that concerns you. When you explain what happened, describe how your health changed afterward. Unlike Potestio Law, which lists personal injury within its broader practice, ERICKSONS LLP and de Bakker Law expressly list medical malpractice. You can use that label as a starting point. Whether a lawyer has handled a claim like yours isn't clear from it.
Without asking for private client details, you can ask about comparable cases. Ask who would take responsibility for your file, including who would read your chart. Published malpractice results aren't available from any of these firms. When you first speak, ask about what you couldn't learn from a website or client review.
Put the deadline ahead of the search
If the claim is a child's, different timing rules apply. While a child is under 18 and has no litigation guardian for the claim (someone acting for the child in the lawsuit), the 2-year period doesn't run. If a claim arises while a child has no litigation guardian, the ultimate period is also suspended. Discuss your child's circumstances with a lawyer.
Ask for clear fees and communication
According to Potestio Law, it offers a free consultation and contingency fees. What does that consultation cover? The other firms may not offer those same arrangements.
If the claim fails, a contingency arrangement means no lawyer's fee; if there's a recovery, the lawyer takes a share as their fee. What would records and medical opinions cost, separately from the court fees?
Before costs come up, ask for a written explanation of who pays them and what you could owe if the claim fails.
Decide how you'll get updates, including whom you should contact. Callback concerns appear in ERICKSONS LLP's reviews, while a complaint about de Bakker Law concerns file handling and fees.
If someone promises a result before reviewing the medical facts, be wary of them. You don't need a certificate of merit to start an Ontario claim. Because court rules still require service of expert reports on the standard of care and causation, ask how the lawyer would obtain those reports. This gives general information, not legal advice.
Questions people ask
How long do I have to start a malpractice claim in Thunder Bay?
Discovery starts Ontario's basic limitation period of 2 years. The treatment date isn't necessarily when that period starts. You discover a claim when you know, or reasonably ought to know, that you were injured and a provider contributed to the injury, and that a lawsuit was appropriate. Another deadline is the 15-year ultimate period. Before relying on your dates, ask an Ontario lawyer how the rules apply.
Do the same deadlines apply to a child's claim?
While a child is under 18 and has no litigation guardian for the claim, the 2-year period doesn't run. If a claim arises while the child is a minor without a litigation guardian, the 15-year ultimate period is also suspended. These rules are addressed in Wong v. Lui, 2023 ONCA 272. Ask an Ontario lawyer how those rules apply before you rely on an extended deadline.
Can I speak to a listed lawyer without paying for the consultation?
According to Potestio Law, its consultation is free. Before booking with ERICKSONS LLP or de Bakker Law, check, because we haven't confirmed that for them. Before the meeting, ask what it covers and whether reviewing records carries a separate charge. A free first conversation doesn't necessarily mean you won't pay for medical opinions or the work needed to pursue a claim.
What does a medical malpractice claim need?
You'll need to address the standard of care (the care expected of the provider) and whether a failing caused the injury, which is the question of causation. To start an Ontario claim, you don't need an affidavit or certificate of merit. Court rules still require, in practice, that expert reports addressing those issues be served. Given your situation, which records and opinions would the lawyer need?
How long will my claim take?
Families can't all use the same case-length estimate. Although the filing deadline tells you when to start a claim, it doesn't tell you when it'll finish. Once the lawyer reviews the records, what needs to happen, and how will they obtain expert reports? Ask how they'll keep you posted on progress, too. You can't establish a timetable from published malpractice results, because none of the listed firms publishes them.
Is there a limit on compensation in Ontario?
Economic losses such as lost income or future care aren't subject to a statutory cap in Ontario. For non-pecuniary damages, which cover losses such as pain and suffering, a judge-made national cap does set a limit. You can't tell what your claim is worth from that distinction. When you discuss your circumstances, an Ontario lawyer can explain which losses may apply and what you'd need to support them.
What should I do before contacting a Thunder Bay lawyer?
When you write down your treatment dates, note when you first thought the care might have caused an injury. Collect the hospital letters you have, along with your medical records. When you call, ask about the deadline and whether the firm has handled similar care. Before the first conversation, you don't need every document, and you can ask the lawyer what they need next.
Can I ask about a claim if my loved one died?
If you think medical care may have contributed to your loved one's death, you can discuss that with a lawyer. Along with any records you have, bring a timeline of what happened. Ask an Ontario lawyer who may bring a claim and which losses may be claimed. How the limitation rules apply is something they can also explain. You can't establish these firms' experience with claims involving a death just by reading their practice listings.
How much weight should I give online reviews?
When you read reviews, use them to plan questions about service rather than predict a result. Clients of Potestio Law say they felt supported. Alongside positive accounts, ERICKSONS LLP's feedback raises concerns about responses; de Bakker Law's reviews often describe responsiveness, although one complaint concerns file handling and fees. Published malpractice results aren't available from any of these firms. When you contact each firm, ask about comparable medical negligence work.