On this page(6)
When care falls below the required standard and causes an injury, that's medical malpractice. An outcome can be poor without malpractice. Whether the provider's substandard care caused the harm is what matters, as Bostwick & Peterson's explanation of malpractice claims emphasizes. Start with what happened if you're worried about treatment. To learn how the rules apply to your situation, ask a lawyer in your state or province.
Before you reach a legal conclusion, you can ask for help. Even if you know your condition got worse, you might not know whether treatment caused it. Rather than guessing to fill the gaps, say what you're still uncertain about.
What makes care potentially negligent?
When healthcare falls below the required standard, that care is negligent. To make a malpractice claim, you also need to connect that care to your injury. According to Bostwick & Peterson, patients must demonstrate that their injuries were more likely than not caused by substandard care.
That connection is called causation.
If inadequate treatment or follow-up comes after a diagnosis, it may raise a malpractice concern, as Morgan & Morgan explains. Notice that “May”. Even when a decision is troubling, it doesn't establish why an injury happened.
As you write down what happened for the first time, keep the care you question separate from the harm. A concern about care might read, “I wasn't given follow-up instructions”. In a separate account of what happened afterward, explain what you know and what you're still unsure about.
Communication problems deserve a closer look
According to Duke Health, gaps in care coordination and miscommunication about patient expectations are among the issues that can provoke malpractice lawsuits. It also points to patients not being adequately engaged in care.

If something felt wrong, these concerns can help you describe it. Perhaps the next step in treatment was something you couldn't get a clear answer about. Write down your question and the answer you received, rather than describing the care as “bad,” without that detail.
Not every communication failure establishes negligence, and Duke's discussion doesn't suggest otherwise. Whether substandard care caused an injury is a separate legal question. When a lawyer reviews your account of the communication problem, they can consider that question.
Prepare a clear account before a consultation
For the lawyer to review, describe what actually happened. You don't need medical vocabulary. If you're unsure about something, flag it in your own words rather than guessing why a provider acted as they did.
Write a treatment timeline
Describe the care that concerns you first, including any dates you know. After naming the provider or facility, describe what happened afterward. Make approximate dates clear.
Identify the decision you question
If treatment or follow-up seemed inadequate, describe what concerned you. If communication is your concern, record your question along with the answer you were given.
Describe the injury separately
After the care, what changed for you? Ask the lawyer what they'd need to assess the connection, since the order of events doesn't prove causation by itself.
Gather documents you already have
Along with messages, gather the relevant chart pages and discharge instructions. To help the lawyer assess your concern, ask which other records they'd need.
If someone told you something, distinguish it from what you saw firsthand. As long as the timeline identifies who witnessed each event, a family member can help you write it. Keep both accounts if they differ (even when one sounds stronger).
Check the deadline early
Patients don't all have the same deadline for filing. According to National Trial Law, many medical malpractice claims have a two-year statute of limitations, although the state may set shorter deadlines for some cases.

Treating that as your own deadline isn't a safe assumption. To find out which rule applies and when the clock starts, ask a local lawyer. Ask about the filing deadline before you've finished organizing every document, rather than waiting until you're done.
Keep expectations grounded
Even a troubling outcome doesn't, by itself, support a claim. Someone needs to assess the care and its connection to the injury. An average settlement doesn't tell you what your situation is worth, and you shouldn't assume malpractice lawsuits are easy to win.
When you consult a lawyer, ask what they see as the biggest uncertainty. Whether the care fell below the required standard may be in question, or they may question whether it caused the injury. Before pursuing the case, ask about the cost and what further review would involve.
What to do next
As you gather the documents you already have, write a short timeline. To discuss it, contact a lawyer handling medical malpractice in your state or province. Early in that conversation, ask when the filing deadline falls. If you're a US reader, our medical malpractice lawyer guide is another starting point.
Common questions
Is it easy to win a medical malpractice lawsuit?
What is negligence in healthcare?
What is the average medical malpractice settlement?
How long does a medical malpractice case take to settle?
Sources
- How Do I Know If I Have a Medical Malpractice Case?, Bostwick & Peterson
- Medical Malpractice: Why Things Go Wrong, Duke Health
- All of Your Medical Malpractice Questions Answered, Morgan & Morgan
- Medical Malpractice Dos and Don'ts, National Trial Law


