On this page(6)
For a medical malpractice claim, you need four elements: duty of care, breach of that duty, causation and damages. They must connect: you need to show how a provider's obligation to care for you led to negligent care that caused harm. Although these elements explain what the claim must establish, they don't cover every procedural requirement for filing a lawsuit.
When people discuss these elements, they may call them the “four Ds”: duty, dereliction, direct causation and damage. You'll find those terms in For the People's explanation, but the different labels point to much the same underlying questions.
| Element | What it means | Question to discuss with a lawyer |
|---|---|---|
| Duty of care | The provider had a duty to provide care. | What duty did this provider owe me? |
| Breach of duty | The provider failed to meet that duty through negligent care. | What was wrong with the care? |
| Causation | The negligent care caused the harm being claimed. | How did that failure cause my injury? |
| Damages | The claim involves harm or injury resulting from the breach. | What harm resulted from the negligent care? |
1. Duty: an obligation to provide care
Before you get to whether the care was negligent, start with the provider's duty: the claim must establish that the provider owed you a duty of care. In SFSPA's explanation of the four requirements, this is called “Proof of A Duty to Act.”
When you talk to the lawyer, identify whose care you're questioning and ask what obligation that person or organization had in your situation. Instead of starting with a general feeling that something went wrong with your medical care, you'll have something concrete to discuss: the provider's role.
2. Breach: negligent care
When you look next at the care itself, the question is whether the provider failed to meet the duty of care and therefore breached it. In the four-D framework, this is called “dereliction”; SFSPA describes it as proof of negligent care.
Be specific when you describe your concerns. Instead of stopping at “the treatment didn't work,” tell the lawyer what the provider did, or failed to do, that you believe was wrong. To address this element, ask whether that care breached the provider's duty. You'll address the harm that followed later, as a separate question.
3. Causation: the link between care and harm
To establish causation, you must link negligent care to your injury. In MyAccidentLaw's explanation, “harm or injury due to the breach of care” is named as one of the four elements.
Asking what went wrong with your care doesn't tell you what harm that failure caused. Breach comes before causation in this discussion. Ask your lawyer how breach differs from causation in your situation. Tell the lawyer what you think happened and why you link it to your injury, without trying to reach a legal conclusion (that's not your job).
4. Damages: the harm resulting from the breach
Damages concern the harm you're claiming, which MyAccidentLaw calls damages resulting from the breach and lists as the fourth element. You'll also find damages in Bell Law Firm's explanation, which says the patient must prove injuries.
This doesn't tell you what a settlement might be. Start with the injury, explaining how you think the care caused it. When you ask the lawyer how that harm fits the damages element, also ask what you'd need to support it.
These elements aren't a complete filing checklist
“Needed to file,” as someone might put it, can refer to the parts of a malpractice claim or the court's requirements for bringing one. Knowing the four elements won't tell you whether your complaint is ready to file, since they only address the claim itself.
Ask a lawyer in your state or province which filing rules apply to you, since each has its own rules. The US state pages and Canadian province pages are places you can start looking. Don't mistake the general information in this article for legal advice about your situation.
What to do next
Write down whose care you're concerned about, along with what you think went wrong. Describe the harm that followed as you'd explain it yourself. Bring those questions to a lawyer who handles medical malpractice claims so you can discuss them. Before deciding whether to file, ask which elements need a closer look.
Common questions
Are the four Ds different from the four elements?
Why do some explanations list only three elements?
Which malpractice element is hardest to prove?
Does having all four elements mean I can file immediately?
Sources
- The Four Ds of Medical Negligence: How to Prove Your Claim, For the People
- 4 Requirements for a Med Mal Lawsuit, SFSPA
- What Are the 4 Elements of Malpractice?, MyAccidentLaw
- What You Need to Win Your Medical Malpractice Case, Bell Law Firm


