On this page(5)
When a healthcare provider misdiagnoses a patient or delays a diagnosis, that may breach the standard of care. Operating on the wrong site or leaving an instrument inside a patient can also breach that standard during surgery. Hospital care can fall short during routine tasks, too. Although these examples can help you describe what happened, they don't establish that what happened to you was medical malpractice.
Describe what the provider did first. Explain the specific act and what you believe went wrong if you're worried about your care or a family member's treatment. Describe what happened afterward, too. To understand how the applicable rules relate to those events, ask a lawyer in your state or province.
What a breach of the standard of care means
When a surgeon's actions fall below the standard, a surgical breach occurs, says Levin & Perconti's standard-of-care explainer. What matters is the provider's actions. If a patient is unhappy with the result, that alone isn't what the explainer describes.
Your account should make clear what happened, not just your disappointment. Saying the surgery went badly doesn't tell the person reviewing it which action you're concerned about. Was the surgery done on the wrong site, or was an instrument left inside the patient? Both examples appear in Cohen & Jaffe in its discussion of breaches.
Misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis
When care goes wrong, diagnostic errors are a central example of what can happen. Among the most common forms of medical malpractice are diagnostic errors, according to VSCP Law's discussion of breach and medical malpractice. In Cohen & Jaffe's list of breaches, you'll find both misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis.
Describe which diagnosis concerned you. Write down the diagnosis you were given and the one you later received if you believe the first was wrong. If you're concerned about a delay, identify the dates you want reviewed. Instead of saying “it took too long,” give those specifics.
Don't fill gaps with a guess. If you're unsure about a date, mark it as approximate; if you don't know when someone made a decision, say so. You don't have to sound sure. Your account can explain why you're concerned without pretending you know more about what happened than you do.
You can read more about these diagnostic problems on the misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis page. A lawyer can review the diagnosis and your circumstances with you if you need to know whether what happened amounts to a breach.
Surgical mistakes
Cohen & Jaffe names two specific surgical mistakes: a surgeon operating on the wrong site or leaving instruments inside a patient. These examples concern what someone did during the surgery. Neither describes recovery being difficult in a general sense.
What first alerted you to the problem? You may have heard about it from someone directly; perhaps you read something in your chart that you needed someone to explain. You can say you're unsure while making clear which parts came from a provider and which are your own suspicions. You don't have to settle what you're unsure about before someone reviews your care.
| Concern | Published example | A useful question to bring |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnostic error | Misdiagnosis | What diagnosis was given, and what do I believe was wrong about it? |
| Diagnostic delay | Delayed diagnosis | Which dates or decisions do I want reviewed? |
| Wrong-site surgery | Operating on the wrong site | What site was intended, and what site was operated on? |
| Retained instrument | Leaving an instrument inside a patient | What was I told about the instrument, and when? |
| Routine hospital care | Not providing a patient's meal on time | What care was expected, and what happened instead? |
Cohen & Jaffe provides the examples above about problems with diagnosis and surgery. For the meal example, it's the journal article discussed below. Although the questions can help you explain your experience, they aren't a legal test.
Failures in routine hospital care
You can have concerns about care that doesn't involve surgery. Not providing a patient's meal on time is an example of procedural neglect in a hospital given in the 2021 article “Patient negligence in healthcare systems: Accountability ...”, available through ScienceDirect. The article says the missed meal breaches a procedure that's already known and documented.
The meal example needs a closer look. The article calls it procedural neglect, but you can't use that description to tell whether a late meal in your circumstances supports a malpractice claim. Missing one routine task may have a different legal meaning from missing another, even though both are part of hospital care.
Describe the routine task that concerns you, including what you actually saw happen during that care. Write down what happened instead of just calling it “neglect,” without giving any details. You can start reading about problems with this kind of care on the hospital and nursing negligence page.
What to do next
Before you contact a lawyer, write a short, readable account that shows which questions you still can't answer.
- Name what you want reviewed, whether that's a delayed diagnosis or a surgical mistake someone reported to you.
- Write down the dates you know; label uncertain ones approximate.
- Write down who told you about the problem without mixing your concerns into what they said.
- Ask which records the lawyer needs and how the rules where you received care apply to you.
This gives general information, not legal advice. A lawyer in your US state or Canadian province can help you review what happened in your circumstances. Bring along your written account. When you ask the lawyer to review the specific conduct, don't assume that seeing it among these examples settles your case.
Common questions
Is a breach of the standard of care the same as malpractice?
What diagnostic problems can raise a standard-of-care concern?
Can a missed routine hospital task be a breach?
Sources
- What is the difference between Breach of the Standard of Care & Medical Malpractice?, VSCP Law
- What Is the Standard of Care?, Levin & Perconti
- Breach of the Standard of Care in a Medical Malpractice ..., Cohen & Jaffe
- Patient negligence in healthcare systems: Accountability ..., ScienceDirect


