On this page(5)
General surgeons and obstetricians/gynecologists are among the doctors most likely to be sued for medical negligence. Both groups appear at the top in Adler's article, “Which Medical Specialties Have the Most Malpractice Suits?”. That's it, in brief. If you're looking for one undisputed leader across every measure or across both the United States and Canada, the article doesn't establish one.
Don't overlook that difference. If your treatment worries you, you'll learn much more by looking at what happened during your care than at the doctor's field. Don't read a lawsuit ranking as a finding about your doctor.
What “most sued” actually measures
When a headline says “Most sued”, it might count lawsuits involving a field, for instance, or tell you what percentage of doctors in that field have ever faced one. You can't swap those measures. Before you rely on a ranking, check what it counts.
| Measure | What it answers | What it doesn't establish |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage sued during a career | How many doctors in a group have faced at least one lawsuit | How often they are sued in any single year |
| Total number of lawsuits | How many lawsuits were counted for a group | The percentage of that group's doctors who were sued |
| Settlements or court results | What happened in the cases being reported | The outcome of every lawsuit involving that field |
In Adler's article, the doctors described as most likely to be sued are general surgeons and OB/GYNs. If you're judging their care, that statement isn't a verdict; it only describes how likely they are to face lawsuits. Nor does it let you rank an individual physician.
Age and career length need a separate look
When Western Summit's article, “Older Physicians and Surgical Specialists Face Higher Lawsuit Exposure,” gives a figure about physicians' age, it names the American Medical Association as its source: 45.2% of physicians age 55 and older had been sued at least once during their careers.
That's a whole career. Don't read it as saying 45.2% were sued in a single year or 45.2% committed malpractice. Although Western Summit gives the AMA's figure on that page, you won't find the original survey published there.
Check which doctors the statistic covers. If you're comparing general surgeons with OB/GYNs, a figure about older physicians doesn't answer the same question. Combining the two won't give you a ranking you can rely on.
Does a higher lawsuit rate mean worse care?
You can't conclude that here. When a doctor is sued, they're facing a legal allegation, not, by that fact alone, a finding that they acted negligently. You can't judge your treatment from the figures reported by Adler and Western Summit.
If you've had an operation or a difficult delivery, you may be reading this now. Whether negligent care harmed you isn't something the ranking answers (it's just background). To assess what happened during your care, ask a lawyer.
What patients in the US and Canada should take from this
You won't find an established Canadian ranking in Adler or Western Summit. If you're comparing provinces, their reports don't prove that the same doctors lead lawsuit statistics everywhere. Nor should you assume they compare individual states in the US.
Which legal rules apply depends on the state or province. If you ask a lawyer where you received care, they can explain the rules that apply to you, including the statute of limitations. To read about the place where you received care, start with the US state pages or Canadian province pages.
Treat this as general information, not legal advice. Whether you have a claim isn't something lawsuit statistics can tell you, nor can they tell you what the outcome might be.
What to do if you're concerned about your care
First, recall what you can. When you write it down, separate what you personally observed from what someone told you later. Mark any chart entries or delivery notes that concern you if you have records. There's no need to tie your experience to a national ranking.
Before a lawyer reviews your case, ask which records they need to examine and find out which dates matter under local law. Whether general surgeons or OB/GYNs rank first isn't something you need to settle before asking about the care you received.
If you're a US reader, start with our medical malpractice page. You can also visit the obstetrical malpractice page if your concerns involve pregnancy or delivery. To request a case review, then contact a lawyer in the state or province where you received treatment.


