Skip to content
Malpractice Center

The Most Common Reasons Doctors Are Sued for Malpractice

In one US study of paid claims, diagnosis errors lead. Reports also flag birth injuries; surgical negligence and infections appear too.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(6)

When patients bring medical malpractice claims, diagnosis errors are a leading reason. According to a study published in JAMA Internal Medicine in 2017, diagnosis errors accounted for 31.8% of paid claims involving US physicians, making them the most common allegation. In other sources, birth injuries appear alongside surgical negligence as common claim categories. That isn't a ranking of all lawsuits filed in the US or Canada.

What happened during the patient's care matters more to your family than any ranking does. If there's a missed diagnosis or an infection, you may have concerns, including about a death. Those descriptions aren't enough, though, to tell you whether there's a malpractice case.

What the numbers actually show

Share of paid claims alleging a diagnosis error in the 2017 JAMA Internal Medicine study
31.8%
Source
Paid claims involving diagnosis-error allegations, out of 111,066 paid claims studied
35,349
Source

Notice the word paid. When the journal counted claims, it included those resulting in payment, not every allegation or lawsuit. The physicians studied were in the US. You can't read its figure as a Canadian claim rate or use it to tell what percentage of doctors have been sued.

In that study's dataset, diagnosis errors clearly lead. You can't use the study, though, to rank every reason patients currently sue across the US and Canada. If you're trying to describe your experience, a list of common concerns can help. A label alone won't tell you about your doctor's care.

Misdiagnosis, delayed diagnosis and no diagnosis

Because the JAMA study identifies diagnosis errors as its largest allegation group, it provides the strongest support for that category. Delayed or nonexistent diagnosis also appears among the reasons to consider a claim in Miller & Stern's malpractice article.

Put events in order. When you write down the symptoms you reported, include when you reported them and what the doctor said at each visit. Record a later appointment separately if you received a different diagnosis then. Keep the visits distinct in your account.

When describing what you observed, keep it separate from your interpretation. An event is described by “I reported pain at this visit”. To say “The doctor should have diagnosed me then” requires someone to assess the care. When you bring both concerns to a lawyer, make clear which details you remember and which questions you still need help answering.

If you're in the US, our misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis page can help you start learning about that practice area.

Questions about your own case?

Surgical negligence

Surgical negligence appears among common Florida claim categories in the Florida Trial Team's article, “What Are the Most Common Medical Malpractice Cases?”. Because it describes claims in that state, you won't find a national percentage there.

Start by writing down the procedure's name and date if you're concerned about an operation. When describing what worried you afterward, don't assume the outcome tells you what caused it.

Before the consultation, gather the surgical records you already have. If you don't understand a passage, mark it (you needn't interpret it yourself). To help answer your questions, ask the lawyer which additional records you should gather.

Birth injuries

On the Florida Trial Team's list of common malpractice claims, you'll also find birth injuries. You can't tell from that description how often those claims occur compared with diagnosis errors or surgical allegations.

If you're a parent, keeping the delivery account separate from what happened afterward may help you describe the events. When you write down your memories of labor, note when someone first explained your child's injury afterward. Rather than using a label you've found online, use the diagnosis in the child's records.

If the delivery notes raise questions, bring them. When family members remember events differently, keep their accounts separate instead of combining them into one. If you're in the US, you can also visit our birth injury page.

Infections and a loved one's death

According to Miller & Stern's article, someone might consider a malpractice claim because of a developed infection or a loved one's death. Either may raise questions. You can't conclude from either that a doctor acted negligently.

Be specific about what concerns you. If you're concerned about an infection, write down when symptoms first appeared and when you contacted the care team. Identify the decisions or events you'd like reviewed if someone died. Before asking someone to assess the care, you don't have to determine the cause yourself.

You can't tell what happened in the hospital from an infection alone. Nor can you establish why a death occurred from the death itself. If you're in the US, our hospital-acquired infections page can help you start learning about that concern.

What to do next

Write a short account before your consultation. After describing the care that concerns you, explain what changed afterward. If you know the dates, give them; mark dates you're unsure about as approximate.

  • If you already have chart pages or other medical records, collect them.
  • If you exchanged messages with the doctor or hospital, keep them.
  • When listing your questions, include which records you still need to get.

Don't choose a claim just because its label sounds familiar. To assess what happened to you, ask a lawyer. Because rules differ by state and province, you can start locally with our US state pages or Canadian province pages. Treat this as general information, not legal advice. To understand how the rules apply to your situation, speak with a lawyer in your state or province.

Common questions

What is the most common reason doctors face malpractice claims?
Diagnosis errors led the allegations in the 2017 JAMA Internal Medicine study, which looked at paid claims involving US physicians. Of the claims studied, 31.8% involved diagnosis errors. Because these were paid claims, don't confuse them with every lawsuit. You can't apply that ranking to Canada.
Does an infection mean I have a malpractice case?
You can't tell from an infection alone. Although Miller & Stern lists a developed infection as a reason someone might consider a claim, you can't tell what happened during your care from that label. When recording symptoms, note their appearance and what you reported. To have your concern assessed, speak with a lawyer in your state or province.
Which type of doctor gets sued the most?
You can't tell from the diagnosis-error percentage. Because it groups allegations by the type of error, it doesn't show which field of medicine faces the most lawsuits. That figure won't let you rank doctors by practice area, and you can't infer from it how often an individual physician has been sued.
Is it worth asking a lawyer to review what happened?
If you still have concerns about the care, you can ask someone to assess it. Before asking, you don't have to decide that malpractice occurred. Once you've prepared a short account and gathered the records you have, ask what further information the lawyer needs and how the local rules apply to you. Having the care reviewed doesn't promise a lawsuit or payment.

Sources

  1. Paid Malpractice Claims Among US Physicians by Specialty, 1992–2014, JAMA Internal Medicine
  2. 11 Reasons Why You Might Have a Medical Malpractice Claim, Miller & Stern
  3. What Are the Most Common Medical Malpractice Cases?, Florida Trial Team

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.