Skip to content
Malpractice Center

How to Choose a Medical Malpractice Lawyer

Before comparing the lawyer’s malpractice work and trial experience, read the fee agreement. Who will review your records and handle your case? Ask next.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(7)

When you speak with a medical malpractice lawyer, ask about similar cases and trial experience. Have them explain how they'd review your records. Get the fee terms in writing before you hire anyone. A reassuring conversation isn't enough, so ask who will handle your case and have the lawyer explain what would happen next.

Say what's worrying you. Start there. Before speaking to a lawyer, you don't need to put a legal label on what went wrong. Explain the care you received and what happened afterward, then point out where you think someone made a mistake. What would the lawyer need to investigate before taking your case? Get an explanation.

Look for relevant malpractice work

How much malpractice work does the lawyer do? Have them tell you whether they've handled cases involving the care that concerns you. If a firm broadly describes its personal injury work, that doesn't answer your question; a page listing medical malpractice as a practice area doesn't either.

Get more specific. If a diagnosis was missed, ask about misdiagnosis cases. A general answer about hospital claims won't tell you about birth injury work, so ask about that if the care during delivery concerns you.

You can look for someone to contact through medical malpractice lawyers or use a page that covers your concern, such as birth injury or stroke misdiagnosis. A listing gives you someone to contact. It can't tell you whether that lawyer is right for your case.

Ask about trial experience and medical review

In How to Select a Medical Malpractice Lawyer | Ohio Attorney, the emphasis is on experience trying complex medical malpractice cases. Readers of How do I choose an attorney are also directed to look for extensive trial experience. Even if you only want someone to review what happened right now, ask about trial experience when you meet with the lawyer.

Hands review a blank medical file beside a stethoscope, glasses, and pen

In previous cases, what did the lawyer personally do? Ask. If the case went to trial, did they handle it or did another firm attorney? Ask who would stay involved if your case went forward, particularly whether it would be the lawyer you're meeting.

According to Medical Malpractice Lawyer: 5 Must-Have Qualities, access to medical experts is something to consider when choosing a lawyer. How would the firm arrange for someone to review your care? Ask. Who pays for that review? An encouraging first conversation doesn't tell you whether a medical expert has looked at what happened to you yet.

Questions about your own case?

Use the consultation to compare concrete answers

When you meet each lawyer, use the same questions. While you still remember the conversation, write down the answers and note what the lawyer couldn't answer yet. Instead of trying to remember how convincing a sales pitch sounded, you'll have the lawyer's actual answers in front of you to compare.

Questions to ask before hiring a medical malpractice lawyer
Ask aboutQuestion to useWhat to clarify
Relevant workHave you handled claims involving this kind of treatment or diagnosis?The lawyer's personal role, rather than the firm's general practice description.
Trial experienceWhat medical malpractice cases have you personally tried?Who would handle your case if it went to trial.
Medical reviewHow would you obtain a medical expert's assessment?The proposed review process and its cost.
FeesCan you walk me through the written fee agreement?How the legal fee is calculated and when payment is due.
ExpensesWhat expenses could I owe if the case doesn't proceed or produces no recovery?Any financial responsibility separate from the lawyer's fee.
CommunicationWho will be my contact after I hire the firm?How to reach that person and how updates will be handled.

Read the fee agreement before signing

A brief explanation won't tell you enough about the fee. If wording in the proposed agreement isn't clear, ask the lawyer to explain it. Find out what this firm would charge under this contract. That's what you need to know.

If payment depends on a recovery, have the lawyer explain how it works and identify the amount they'd use to calculate the fee. What about case expenses? Also ask what the fee agreement says you could still owe if the firm stops after reviewing your records or your case ends without payment.

Save a copy yourself. If the written terms don't match what you thought the lawyer said during your conversation, have them explain the difference before you sign.

Put published results in context

A result on a firm's website gives you something to ask about, but it doesn't predict what will happen for your family. Ask what the lawyer you're considering did in that case and whether the care was like yours. Don't choose a lawyer just because of the dollar amount.

Hand sorting blank papers beside a folder, reading glasses, and a pen on a kitchen table

If a lawyer mentions a success rate, find out which cases count toward it. Is every inquiry counted there? Are they counting accepted cases or just cases with a reported result? Get that explanation before you try to compare the figures.

When the lawyer discusses uncertainty, listen to their wording. Ask what they still need to learn about your situation and what could change their assessment. Don't accept pressure to believe a promised outcome, because a careful review still needs to leave room for those questions.

Prepare for the first conversation

Write a short account that tells what happened in your own words. If you know the dates, include them; mark anything you're unsure about. To help the lawyer see what needs further review, keep what concerns you separate from what the chart actually says about your care.

Have the firm tell you which records it wants and how to send them. Ask. If you already have discharge paperwork or delivery notes, mention them. If you're missing records, find out whether the firm will help you get them.

Your next step

When the firm responds to your request for a case review, check its answers against the questions above. Don't hire the firm until you've read its proposed fee agreement and confirmed who will handle your case. Ask again if an answer isn't clear. You aren't making a commitment just by having that first conversation.

Common questions

How do I know whether I have a medical malpractice case?
After describing your treatment and concerns to a lawyer, ask what they'd need in order to assess what happened to you. You can't decide that just from the outcome. Before the firm accepts your case, would it have a medical expert review your records? Have the lawyer explain what questions that review would need to answer.
Should I choose a lawyer based on a large settlement?
Don't hire a lawyer just because you've seen a published dollar amount. Ask what the lawyer personally did in that case and whether it involved care like yours. You can't tell what your case could produce by looking at past results. When the firm explains how it would review your care, listen closely, including to the way it answers questions about your particular circumstances.
What should I ask about legal fees?
Get a written agreement. Before discussing expenses separately (including medical review costs), ask the lawyer to explain how they'd calculate the fee. If payment depends on a recovery, what could you owe without one? Find out. Don't sign until you've resolved any difference between what the written terms say and what you understood when you met with the lawyer.
Does the lawyer need trial experience?
When you meet the lawyer, ask about trial experience. In their discussions of malpractice representation, both How to Select a Medical Malpractice Lawyer | Ohio Attorney and How do I choose an attorney emphasize trial experience. If your case went to trial, who would handle it? Ask that along with what trial work the lawyer has personally done in previous cases.

Sources

  1. How to Select a Medical Malpractice Lawyer | Ohio Attorney, Not identified
  2. How do I choose an attorney, Not identified
  3. Medical Malpractice Lawyer: 5 Must-Have Qualities, Not identified

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.