Skip to content
Malpractice Center

Getting the Right Diagnosis: Tips for Patients

Before your visit, write down your symptom history clearly. Ask for an explanation of the diagnosis and a follow-up plan you can understand.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(6)

To help your clinician understand what's happening, bring your symptom history in writing. Ask why the proposed diagnosis fits, and make sure the follow-up plan makes sense to you. Say what's still unanswered if the explanation doesn't address your concern. Preparing this way gives you something to work from in the conversation, but it doesn't promise a diagnosis at that visit.

It's okay to arrive without the answer. Explain what you've experienced, including what you still need explained. Although this guide offers questions for your care team, it can't diagnose your symptoms or take the place of medical advice.

Start with what happened, in your own words

Write a short account before your appointment, beginning with when you first noticed the problem that's worrying you most. Describe any changes. Rather than searching for a medical label, use your own words to explain how it affects something concrete, such as eating or getting through a workday.

Keep your guesses separate from what you've actually observed. Instead of deciding the medication caused it, you might write, “This started before I changed my medication,” in your notes. Is the date unclear? If you aren't sure, mark it as approximate rather than filling gaps with uncertain details.

  • Alongside your main concern, write down the question you most want someone to answer.
  • When you note your symptoms, include whether they've changed since your last visit.
  • If you'd like the clinician to review any records, bring those with the names of your medications.
  • If you've had earlier visits for this concern, include the explanation or next step you were given.

If you're speaking for a family member, make clear which details you saw and which they told you. Observing that she left a meal unfinished doesn't tell you the same thing as “She said she felt nauseated” does. Before speaking on their behalf, ask what they want you to raise if that's possible.

Ask for the reasoning, not only the name

Ask how the diagnosis fits your symptoms when the clinician gives it a name. It's okay to request plain language. You don't need to propose a diagnosis yourself; if they haven't reached an answer, ask which possibilities they're considering and what the next step is.

Hands discussing a blank sheet beside a pen, stethoscope, and reading glasses

Daily nausea was the symptom one commenter described in a Reddit discussion about getting a diagnosis. According to their account, possible pregnancy came up, and the appointment ended without a test. Although this anonymous story isn't a verified medical record, it shows how you might bring a question back to the clinician: “What happens next with the symptom I came in about?”

Questions to take into the appointment
  1. Clarify the current answer

    Try asking, “Is this a confirmed diagnosis, or a possible explanation you're still evaluating?” Write down the clinician's own words if you can.

  2. Connect the explanation to your concern

    Try asking, “How does that explain the symptom that's bothering me most?” If something still feels unaddressed, say so.

  3. Discuss the proposed testing

    Find out what question the suggested test should answer. Rather than assuming you know the reason, ask why the clinician isn't ordering a test you expected.

  4. Agree on the next contact

    Find out how to reach the person who'll discuss your results with you. Ask when to follow up if no test is planned. Before leaving, ask which changes mean you should call sooner or seek urgent care.

Questions about your own case?

Make room for the concern that wasn't heard

Be direct about what's missing. You could say, “I understand your explanation, but I'm still concerned about this change.” After describing the change you mean, ask how the clinician took the information you shared into account when explaining your concern.

In a separate Reddit account about patient and family observations, a mother describes noticing a smell before her baby became sick again. That doesn't make the story a diagnostic method. Tell the clinician exactly what you observed if a pattern keeps recurring, and ask whether that pattern should be part of their assessment.

If you're worried you'll lose your train of thought, bring your question in writing. Someone you trust can come along to take notes, if you'd like to have them there. Your own concern should stay at the center of the discussion.

Leave with a plan you can explain back

Check your understanding before leaving by saying, “My next step is this, and I should contact your office if this happens. Is that right?” Ask the clinician to make any vague answer clearer for you. For something to refer to later, you can request written instructions.

Patient and clinician gesture over a blank sheet beside a folder, pen, and reading glasses

Find out how results will reach you. Rather than leaving with those questions unanswered, ask whether another appointment is planned and whom you should contact if you haven't heard anything. Your symptom notes are a place to keep these instructions.

If you still don't have an explanation

When you return for follow-up, explain what's happened since the last appointment. Ask whether the earlier plan needs to change, bringing the conversation back to it. To share the first assessment with another clinician, ask how to get those records if you'd like a second opinion.

An online story shouldn't become the diagnosis you give yourself. If it raises a concern, make that a question to put to your clinician. Nothing in the accounts above establishes what caused those symptoms or shows whether the care anyone received was negligent.

What to do next if you're concerned about a diagnostic error

If you're concerned about care, request the records for it. Keep a separate, dated account of your own, noting what you reported and what you were told. If you don't clearly remember details, mark them.

Reading about misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis can help if you're considering a legal review. Which rules apply depends on your state or province. The US state pages or Canadian province pages are places to look for local information. Because this is general information rather than legal advice, ask a lawyer in your state or province how the rules apply to your situation.

Common questions

What should I bring to an appointment about unexplained symptoms?
When you write a short history of your main concern, include when it began and what's changed. Put your most pressing question at the top, then include medication names and any records you'd like the clinician to review. Make any uncertainty clear. Rather than making your account sound more certain than it is, say when there's a detail you don't remember.
How can I ask about a diagnosis without sounding confrontational?
To ask for the clinician's reasoning in plain language, try: “Can you explain how this fits what I've described?” If a concern remains unanswered, name it. Until you understand an explanation, you don't have to agree with it; keep the conversation focused on your symptoms and on what you're being asked to do next.
What should I ask before leaving without a diagnosis?
If testing or another visit might be planned, ask about that along with the possibilities the clinician is considering and what happens next. Find out which changes mean you should contact them sooner or seek urgent care. Are results still pending? If you haven't heard, whom should you contact, and who will discuss those results with you?
Can an online account show that my diagnosis was wrong?
Because an anonymous account doesn't review your care, the Reddit stories discussed here can't establish your diagnosis or show that anyone was negligent. Write down a question for your clinician if a story raises a concern for you. If you want someone to assess your own treatment legally, speak with a lawyer in your state or province.

Sources

  1. Trying to get a medical diagnosis starter pack, Reddit, r/starterpacks
  2. Discussion of patient and family observations, Reddit, r/AskReddit

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.