Skip to content
Malpractice Center

Can a Doctor Be Held Accountable for Misdiagnosis?

If negligent care caused harm, a wrong diagnosis may support a malpractice claim. Still, a mistake doesn't, by itself, establish liability.

Sources checked

A radiologist studying a chest x-ray on a lightbox
On this page(5)

If negligent care directly harms a patient, a doctor may be legally accountable for making the wrong diagnosis. Malpractice requires more than a wrong diagnosis. According to Burnside Law Firm, the distinction is whether a diagnostic error involves negligence that causes harm; other errors don't give a patient grounds for a malpractice claim.

If your diagnosis changed after earlier medical visits, your first question should be what went wrong with the care. What harm did that error then cause? To understand how the rules apply to your situation, talk with a lawyer in your state or province. This information isn't advice about your case.

A diagnostic mistake and malpractice aren't the same

The questions aren't interchangeable. Finding out that an earlier diagnosis was wrong can feel especially upsetting if you think you lost time. The later diagnosis can't, by itself, tell you whether the earlier care was negligent or whether it caused an injury.

Tell the lawyer which diagnosis you think was wrong, along with the harm you believe it caused. Explain more than “the doctor got it wrong.” Describe what happened afterward and why you think the error made things worse, without guessing how the two are medically connected. How should that question be evaluated? Ask a lawyer.

A missed or delayed diagnosis may also matter

Perhaps the illness you're concerned about wasn't identified at all, instead of being diagnosed as something else. According to Wagner Reese, delaying or failing to diagnose an illness or injury may constitute malpractice. A claim needs more than a delay.

Tell the story in order. Starting with what you were told at the first visit, explain when the diagnosis changed. If you initially received no diagnosis, describe that visit as having no diagnosis, not a misdiagnosis. Legal terms aren't needed here.

For more information, see our page about misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis. You can start there, but the page doesn't determine whether your doctor's care was negligent.

Questions about your own case?

Prepare for a conversation about your care

You don't have to decide for yourself whether the care was malpractice. Get what you already know in order before contacting a lawyer, but keep your memories separate from what's in the medical records. Mark anything you're unsure about.

A practical starting point
  1. Write down the sequence

    List the visits you remember. For each visit, note what you reported and what the doctor said, with any dates you can remember. Leave the date blank if you aren't sure you remember it correctly, rather than filling it in with a guess.

  2. Set aside the records you have

    Gather any visit notes you have, along with test results or messages. Ask the lawyer which other records you should request. A missing record doesn't necessarily mean that something went wrong with your care.

  3. Describe the harm separately

    How do you think the diagnostic error changed your situation? Say how. Keep what a clinician told you separate from your own concerns about what you think the error caused.

  4. Ask for a local assessment

    Ask a lawyer in your state or province whether you might have a claim under these circumstances, and have them explain which statute of limitations applies. Before they assess your case, have them explain what information they still need from you to do that.

What about compensation?

According to Davis Kelin, a patient may be entitled to compensation when a malpractice or negligence case involves failure to diagnose. Although payment is possible, there's no promise of it.

A settlement headline can't tell you what to expect in your case; there's no reliable dollar figure to give you here. When you talk with the lawyer, ask which losses the applicable law allows them to consider and what would support those losses.

Get advice for your state or province

Where you live determines which rules apply to you. Our US state pages or Canadian province pages are a starting point for information by location. A lawyer where you received care can explain the rules that apply to you, including the deadline for filing a claim. Don't assume you can use another jurisdiction's filing deadline.

Start by asking for a case review. Bring the records you have and your account of what happened, in order, then ask whether negligent diagnostic care could have caused the harm you experienced. If the answer is still unclear, ask what needs to be clarified before you decide what to do.

Common questions

Can I sue a doctor for diagnosing me incorrectly?
A doctor isn't automatically liable for a wrong diagnosis, which may support a malpractice claim if negligent care directly causes harm. Ask a lawyer in your state or province to review what happened to you. A changed diagnosis alone doesn't show that the care was malpractice.
Can a delayed diagnosis be malpractice?
Yes, that's possible. According to Wagner Reese, delaying or failing to diagnose an illness or injury can constitute malpractice; whether your delay supports a claim needs to be assessed based on your circumstances. When did you seek care, and when was the condition identified? Explain that. How does the alleged delay connect to your harm? Ask.
How much compensation could I receive?
You won't find a dependable dollar figure here. Although Davis Kelin describes compensation as a possibility in a failure-to-diagnose malpractice or negligence case, that doesn't tell you what your outcome will be. When you talk with a local lawyer, ask whether you have a potential claim and which losses the applicable law may allow them to consider.

Sources

  1. When Is a Misdiagnosis Considered Medical Malpractice?, Burnside Law Firm
  2. Is Failure to Diagnose/Delayed Diagnosis Considered Malpractice?, Wagner Reese
  3. Can You Sue a Doctor for Failure to Diagnose, Davis Kelin

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.