Skip to content
Malpractice Center

Best Surgical Error Lawyers in St. Louis, MO (2026)

For this evidence-based 2026 list of St. Louis surgical error lawyers, we reviewed each firm's malpractice cases, comparing published results with its years in practice and what clients said.

Sources checked

4 lawyers and firms

Gateway Arch in St. Louis, Missouri
Photo: Sam valadi, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The short answer

We put Cofman Townsley Attorneys at Law first on this list for its published malpractice recoveries and its work going back to 1973. Check whether the firm has handled surgical injuries like yours before you make that first call. Find out who would handle your case and what you'd pay the firm to review your medical records. You can start checking filing rules with the Missouri malpractice guide.

At a glance

  1. 1Cofman Townsley Attorneys at LawFree consultation4.9 out of 5
  2. 2Gretchen MyersFree consultation4.3 out of 5
  3. 3Hipskind & McAninch, LLCFree consultation5.0 out of 5
  4. 4Goldblatt + SingerFree consultation5.0 out of 5

Best Surgical Error Lawyers in St. Louis

  1. 1

    Best for: Published malpractice recovery history

    Among Cofman Townsley Attorneys at Law's reported recoveries is $4.5 million for medical malpractice, with $4.6 million and $14 million reported separately. We included the firm for those recoveries and for the work it's done since 1973. Although the firm handles personal injury cases beyond medical claims, you'll find surgical errors and medication errors on its site.

    How they were picked

    Stood out in our review for its years of experience and what its clients say.

    We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made

  2. Gretchen Myers logo2

    Best for: Failed surgery and serious injury

    The $500,000 settlement Gretchen Myers reports for failed LASIK surgery involves a claim about the surgical treatment itself. Her other reported malpractice settlements include $2.1 million for an infant who partially lost an arm, with $1.2 million for a stroke misdiagnosed in an emergency room. Although the practice takes other injury cases, it lists surgical errors and hospital negligence among the claims it handles.

    How they were picked

    Stood out in our review for the recognition it has earned and the results it publishes.

    We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made

  3. 3

    Best for: Clear explanations and regular updates

    In reviews of Hipskind & McAninch, LLC, clients often say the firm explained things clearly enough for them to follow what was happening in their cases. One reviewer's description was: “He answered our questions in detail.” We included the firm partly for that client feedback and for its site's discussion of surgical errors and other malpractice claims.

    How they were picked

    Stood out in our review for the recognition it has earned and what its clients say.

    We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made

  4. Not sure who to call first?

    Tell us what happened. A malpractice lawyer who serves St. Louis can look at it with you, and it costs nothing.

  5. Goldblatt + Singer logo4

    Best for: Supportive service and established practice

    Goldblatt + Singer's history in St. Louis goes back to 1949, when it began operating there. Reviewers describe staff who helped them through their cases and kept them up to date. One client described the service as “Always communicating with you.”

    How they were picked

    Stood out in our review for its years of experience and what its clients say.

    We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made

See every malpractice firm in St. Louis

Where they are in St. Louis

A few minutes that might help

Questions about your own case?
How a malpractice claim usually moves in Missouri
  1. 1.Something went wrong

    Write down dates and names while they're fresh.

  2. 2.Get your records

    Ask for your full chart and test results.

  3. 3.Free case review

    A lawyer looks at what happened, free.

  4. 4.Medical opinion

    A doctor checks whether the care fell short.

  5. 5.File before the deadline

    Your lawyer starts the claim before the deadline.

  6. 6.Settlement or trial

    Many claims settle. Some go to a judge or jury.

Your deadline: 2 years from the treatmentRead the Missouri law guide

Each step in more detail
  1. Initial review

    When you tell the lawyer about your operation, include when you noticed the injury. Using those dates, they can check the filing deadline. Although Missouri generally allows two years from the act of neglect, specific exceptions use discovery to set the deadline.

  2. Records and medical opinion

    When discussing your surgical records, ask how the firm would review them and get a written medical opinion. To meet Missouri's affidavit requirement, a legally qualified health care provider must give an opinion that the defendant was negligent and caused the damages.

  3. Filing the complaint

    Filing the complaint is how you start the lawsuit. Before that, ask a Missouri lawyer to explain your filing deadline. A child has until the twentieth birthday to sue under the rule that applies to children. Don't assume the usual deadline for adults applies to your claim.

  4. Affidavit after filing

    You have 90 days to submit the affidavit once you've filed in Missouri. The affidavit confirms that you have the required written opinion from a health care provider. You can get up to 90 more days to submit it if there's good cause.

  5. Case development and resolution

    Ask what further records and testimony the lawyer would need for your claim, including how those would affect plans for settlement or trial. Missouri caps non-economic damages when you bring a claim against health care providers. The cap rises for claims involving catastrophic injury or death.

Malpractice claims in St. Louis: the rules that matter

The filing deadline in Missouri
  1. The clock startsOn the day of the treatment
  2. Time to start a claim2 yearsMiss it and the claim is usually lost.
  3. At the very most10 yearsafter the treatment, with a few exceptions
Limits on damages in Missouri
  • Pain and sufferingCapped at about $481,493
  • All damages togetherNo overall cap
  • Expert paperworkWithin 90 days after filing (extendable by up to 90 more for good cause), file an affidavit that a legally qualified health care provider has given a written opinion that the defendant was negligent and caused the damages.

Read the Missouri law guideWork out your own deadline

Local hospitals

Star ratings from CMS Care Compare. Look up a hospital

Filing deadline for most malpractice claims in Missouri
2 years
Source
Outer limit (statute of repose)
10 years
Source
Hospitals near St. Louis with a CMS star rating
1
Source

What a malpractice lawyer costs in St. Louis

  1. The first callOften free. Ask before you book.
  2. A written agreementThe share the lawyer takes, set out before work starts.
  3. If you recover moneyThe agreed share and the case costs come out of it.
  4. If the claim failsNo legal fee on a contingency agreement. Ask about costs.
Six listed firms say they work on contingency: the lawyer gets a share of any recovery and no lawyer's fee if the claim fails. All offer a free consultation. Later expenses aren't necessarily free, though, and case costs can include medical records and health care provider opinions, along with court fees. The firms' stated terms don't establish who advances those costs or who owes them if there's no recovery. Get those answers and the fee calculation in writing before you sign. Zevan Murphy LLC's contingency arrangement remains unconfirmed.

According to all seven listed firms, consultations are free. Contingency work is also stated by six.

What to bring to your first call

  • Your surgery date, along with the date when you first noticed that you were injured
  • Any surgery records you have, including paperwork from your discharge
  • Who treated you: your surgeon's name and those of the other providers
  • A short written account of what happened
  • Your medical bills, with records of other related expenses
  • Anything the hospital or insurer sent you, including letters or messages
  • Photos showing the injury, if you have any
  • Your child's birth date, if the claim is for a minor

Questions to ask a lawyer

  1. 1Have you handled claims involving this operation, or a surgical error like mine?
  2. 2Who would work on my file, including answering me when I call about it?
  3. 3Which deadline do I have to meet to file?
  4. 4To meet Missouri's requirement, how would you get the medical opinion?
  5. 5How do you calculate the fee I'll owe under your contingency agreement?
  6. 6Who pays the case costs if I don't recover any money?
  7. 7What do you need from me to decide whether you'll take my case?
  8. 8How would Missouri's damage caps affect the way you assess what my claim is worth?

Choose for the operation involved

Don't choose by the biggest published recovery instead of the surgery you had. If a malpractice recovery involved a missed diagnosis, there might have been no mistake during surgery. When you describe the error you suspect, ask what similar cases the lawyer has handled and which records they'd need to review. You can have that conversation without knowing the medical answer yet.

Check what each result involved. Unlike Gretchen Myers's published settlement for failed LASIK surgery, Morgan & Morgan's reported verdict involved a delayed C-section in Hillsborough County, outside St. Louis. A ceiling collapse led to the neck surgery in Hipskind & McAninch, LLC's published recovery. Medical treatment figures in each claim without making them alike.

Ask how your file will be handled

  • Would I be able to discuss my surgery records with the person who reviews them for my case?
  • What injury claims have you handled that involved my procedure or a complication like the one afterward?
  • If my usual contact isn't available, who should I ask for an update on my case?
  • Without sharing another client's private information, could you tell me about a case like mine?

Use reviews to decide what to ask. Although clients praise several firms here for keeping them updated, you'll find more uneven accounts of communication in the reviews of some other firms. You can't tell from a high rating whether a lawyer has handled a case about your operation. If unanswered calls already add to your family's stress, find out how the firm would keep you updated before you agree to hire it.

You'll also need medical review. Missouri requires you to submit an affidavit within 90 days after filing, confirming that a legally qualified health care provider gave a written opinion that negligence caused the damages. A court may give you up to 90 more days if there's good cause. Ask how the firm would obtain the provider's opinion.

Read the agreement before signing

Every firm listed says it offers a free consultation. That doesn't mean the firm will take your case. Most also say they work on contingency, which means the lawyer's fee depends on whether you recover money. Ask for written fee terms that spell out who pays for records and medical opinions if your claim fails.

Be wary of anyone who promises a particular result, especially if they push you to sign without explaining costs. This page gives general information, not advice about your case. A Missouri lawyer can look at your situation and explain how the filing rules might change if a child was injured or someone died.

Questions people ask

What is the deadline for a surgical malpractice claim in St. Louis?
Missouri law generally gives you two years from the act of neglect to file your claim. The rule gives you two years from discovery when a foreign object was left in the body or test results weren't reported. The statute also sets an outer limit of ten years. Ask a Missouri lawyer to check your dates against these rules instead of trying to work out the deadline yourself.
What should I do before calling a surgical error lawyer?
Write down your operation date, including an account of what happened afterward. Gather any surgical records or hospital letters you have, and write down the names of the providers. On your first call, find out what else the lawyer needs from you. Although every firm on this list says the consultation is free, having that conversation doesn't mean the firm has agreed to take your claim.
Do I have to pay a lawyer before the case starts?
For the six listed firms that say they work on contingency, a recovery provides the lawyer's fee as a share; if the claim fails, no lawyer's fee is owed. That excludes expenses. If there's no recovery, would you owe expenses for records and medical opinions, and who would advance those costs? To confirm Zevan Murphy LLC's fee terms, you'll need to ask the firm directly.
What medical support does a Missouri malpractice case need?
Missouri law gives you 90 days after filing to submit an affidavit, which confirms that you have a written opinion from a legally qualified health care provider. The provider must say that the defendant was negligent and that the negligence caused the damages for the opinion to qualify. You may get up to 90 more days to submit the affidavit if there's good cause. Ask the lawyer what they'd do to obtain that opinion about the injury from your surgery.
Does Missouri limit compensation for a surgical injury?
Against health care providers, Missouri limits non-economic damages with caps. Although catastrophic injury and death have a higher cap under the law, all the caps rise by 1.7 percent each year. You won't find the applicable dollar amount in this listing. When discussing your injury with a Missouri lawyer, ask which cap may apply and how it would affect the claim under review.
How long will a surgical error case take?
You won't find a supported estimate of case length in this listing. Although filing and affidavit deadlines are legal requirements, they can't tell you when a case will finish. When you ask what could delay the claim, also ask what medical review still needs to happen. How long your own case would take isn't something the firms' published verdicts and settlements can tell you.
What if my child was injured during surgery?
Under Missouri's rule, a child can sue until the twentieth birthday. To check how that rule applies to your child's situation, ask a Missouri lawyer. Although several listed firms address birth injury, that doesn't by itself establish experience with every pediatric operation. When discussing your child's specific procedure, ask how the firm would get the medical opinion required for the claim.
What if a loved one died after an operation?
Among the practice areas or site topics of several listed firms, you'll find wrongful death. When you speak with a Missouri lawyer, ask whether the circumstances support a claim, who may bring it and which filing deadline applies. For death, Missouri's non-economic damage rules provide a higher cap. To help the lawyer begin assessing what happened, bring the dates of the operation along with any communications from the hospital.
How much weight should I give reviews and published results?
Don't skim over either one. Reviews may tell you how the firm keeps in touch, not whether it has handled an operation like yours. A published recovery may concern malpractice unrelated to surgery, or the patient may have needed an operation later because of an injury rather than negligent surgical care. Ask about cases like yours. What a firm recovered before doesn't tell you how your claim will turn out.

Sources

  1. Missouri Revised Statutes § 516.105, Missouri Revisor of Statutes
  2. Missouri Revised Statutes § 538.210, Missouri Revisor of Statutes
  3. Missouri Revised Statutes § 538.225, Missouri Revisor of Statutes
  4. State Enactments of Selected Medical Liability Reforms (as of 8/27/2026), Medical Professional Liability Association
  5. Contributory Negligence/Comparative Fault Laws in All 50 States (updated 6/10/2026), Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer, S.C.
  6. Hospital General Information, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
  7. Malpractice Center methodology, Malpractice Center

Guides on surgical error

Hurt by medical care in St. Louis? Let's talk it through.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Want your firm included on this list?

Tell us about your firm and we'll be in touch.

  • Best Surgical Error Lawyers in St. Louis, MO (2026)

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.