Skip to content
Malpractice Center

How do you prove misdiagnosis?

Use the medical record to compare the diagnoses first. To check your case, ask a local lawyer what evidence you'd need.

Sources checked

A radiologist studying a chest x-ray on a lightbox
On this page(5)

While you're gathering medical records, put down what happened when the diagnosis changed. A lawyer in your state or province can tell you what evidence you'd need to bring a malpractice claim. A different diagnosis deserves a closer look. Malpractice isn't proven by that alone.

You may have reasons to think the original diagnosis was wrong, but those aren't necessarily the reasons a lawyer could use to question the care. Without guessing at missing details, give the lawyer enough information to look at both questions.

Identify what made you question the diagnosis

If your condition isn't improving or your care is inadequate, you may have been misdiagnosed, according to Friedman & Simon. When doctors give different diagnoses, that's another sign. To start reviewing what happened, look for these signs.

What are you most worried about? Instead of “the doctor missed it,” write down what symptoms you told the doctor about and what you heard back. What did the later clinician explain differently? You may not remember the wording. Mention that.

What happened medically isn't necessarily what matters for a legal claim. To understand your current diagnosis and the care you're getting, ask the clinician treating you. Whether the earlier care could support a claim is something a lawyer can review.

Build a record that someone else can check

Before drawing conclusions, collect the documents. Ask the lawyer which other records to request after you've gathered what you have. If it's your recollection, label it. When someone reads what you've written, they shouldn't mistake something you remember for a medical chart entry.

Prepare for a misdiagnosis case review
  1. Collect the records for the disputed diagnosis

    If you already have visit notes or test reports, collect them with any written follow-up instructions or messages. Which documents are still missing? Mark those without guessing their contents.

  2. Add the later diagnosis

    If another clinician identified a different condition, include that record. When the clinician changed the earlier diagnosis, how did they explain it? You may still be waiting for an explanation; note that.

  3. Write a dated account

    When did you report symptoms and receive the first diagnosis? When you later learned something different, add that date. If you're unsure whether a date is right, mark it as approximate rather than simply copying it from your records.

  4. Describe what happened afterward

    How did the diagnosis or delay affect you in ways that worry you? If a concern comes from a medical record, say that; don't leave readers guessing whether it's something you experienced. Ask the lawyer which other details you'll need to put down.

Don't discard the chart. Your own account belongs beside the original record and shouldn't replace what's there. If a note doesn't match your memory, point it out to the lawyer when you bring your documents and account.

Questions about your own case?

Look for a specific diagnostic problem

When certain tests aren't performed or a patient's physical condition is misinterpreted, the diagnosis can be wrong, according to Crowe & Harris. When you frame your questions, consider those possibilities. What happened in your case isn't established by that list.

Which tests did the clinician consider, for example, and what did the examination show? Was a test left out? If you believe a test should have been considered at a particular visit, identify that visit and ask the reviewing lawyer how they'd evaluate your concern.

According to Wagner Reese, misdiagnosis can also stem from inaccurate test results or malfunctioning diagnostic equipment. Blurry images also count. Whoever gave you the diagnosis didn't necessarily cause every problem that led to it.

Bring the report if a scan or laboratory result is worrying you. Should someone review the underlying images or other records? Ask about that. When you ask how someone performed a test, that's different from asking how they interpreted its result.

Ask what would connect the error to your harm

Make time during the consultation to ask about this. Ask what evidence could show that the suspected diagnostic error caused the harm you're concerned about. Ask the lawyer if a medical opinion would also be needed to review your claim.

Which details are you certain about? A later diagnosis in the record doesn't necessarily tell you what would have happened if treatment had started earlier. Leave that question for someone to review. If it hasn't been answered, don't state it as certain.

Get advice for your state or province

Which statute of limitations and filing requirements apply? Ask a local lawyer. What evidence would you need in your circumstances? Discuss that, too. If you need help where you live, start with the US state pages or Canadian province pages. This is general information, not advice about your case.

For the case review, you'll need the records you have and a short account of what happened. You can also read the misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis page. If you think something's proven, ask what's still unproven and what document or medical review could help settle that question.

Common questions

Does a second diagnosis prove the first doctor was negligent?
If you receive a second diagnosis, you have reason to request a review. According to Friedman & Simon, a different diagnosis from another doctor can be a sign of misdiagnosis. Take records from both doctors. To evaluate the earlier care, what additional evidence would a lawyer need? Ask them.
What should I bring to a misdiagnosis consultation?
For both diagnoses, bring whatever records you have, including test reports and any written instructions about follow-up. When you write a short, dated account of your concerns, clearly label memories you're unsure about. You can get guidance rather than assemble everything alone. Which missing records should you request? Ask the lawyer.
Can an inaccurate test result cause a misdiagnosis?
According to Wagner Reese, an inaccurate test result can cause a misdiagnosis. Equipment malfunction and blurry images also appear in its discussion. When you bring the test report to a consultation, ask what would help tell whether the problem was with the test itself or with how someone interpreted it, if that's what concerns you.
How much compensation can I get for a wrong diagnosis?
You can't judge your own situation from a general payout figure. Ask a lawyer in your state or province whether you might have a claim, and find out what records they'd need to look at the harm you've described. Bring any records that back up your concerns. Ask the lawyer to estimate what the case is worth.

Sources

  1. How Do You Tell if You Have Been Misdiagnosed?, Friedman & Simon
  2. Causes of an Incorrect Diagnosis, Causes of Wrong Diagnosis, Crowe & Harris
  3. Is Failure to Diagnose/Delayed Diagnosis Considered Malpractice?, Wagner Reese

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.