On this page(5)
If an adult has hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), the treating medical team needs to explain their treatment. You can't determine an adult’s treatment from a cooling-therapy recommendation for birth injury. Ask the team to explain your family member's treatment, including why they believe it fits the condition they're treating.
Remember which patients those pages discuss. Because much of the online discussion of HIE concerns newborns, the pages below don't establish a treatment protocol for adults. Nor can they back up a promise of recovery.
Does cooling therapy treat HIE in adults?
On Cerebral Palsy Lawyer’s birth-injury page about HIE, therapeutic hypothermia (also called cooling therapy) is described as a treatment for moderate to severe HIE. Because the page discusses birth injury, that statement tells an adult patient only so much.
When NICU Learning Nest discusses HIE, it's also discussing neonatal intensive care. In its HIE article, the condition is called time-sensitive. That statement is about newborns, not the window for treating an adult.
Neither page can tell you whether an adult needed cooling or whether the hospital missed a deadline for treating that adult. Can the treating physician explain which adult-care guidance they used for this patient's treatment decision? Ask what cooling is meant to do for this patient if the team has brought it up.
Questions to ask about the adult treatment plan
You don't need to know a treatment's name before asking the physician about it. Ask the physician to go through the chart's treatment plan with you and explain any unfamiliar terms. These questions can help you follow the plan as you discuss it with the physician.
| Topic | What to ask |
|---|---|
| Diagnosis | What does HIE mean in this patient's case, and what findings support the diagnosis? |
| Current treatment | What treatment is being given now, and what is each part intended to accomplish? |
| Cooling | Is cooling being considered? What adult-care guidance supports using it or not using it? |
| Recovery | What can you tell us now, and what remains uncertain? |
| Next decisions | When will you reassess the plan, and who should we contact with questions? |
Write down the answers. Ask the team why you're hearing different answers if two of their explanations don't seem to match. A newborn HIE article can't explain why the team gave you different answers.
Can an adult recover from HIE?
An online story won't tell you how your family member will recover. In a Reddit discussion about severe anoxic brain injury, one commenter says they still have disabilities but feel better years later. That's one person's experience. It takes more than that story to verify a prognosis or show that a particular treatment works.
Not knowing can be hard. Ask the treating team what they know about your family member and where they still can't give you an answer. If someone sounds sure about a prediction, ask what the patient's findings show.
If you're worried about the care
A recommendation to cool newborns doesn't show that an adult's medical care was improper. If the care concerns you, ask the team to use the patient's chart as they explain their treatment decisions.
For a separate legal review, you can also turn to a lawyer who handles medical malpractice matters. Treat this as general information, not legal advice. To understand how the rules apply to your situation, ask a lawyer in your state or province.
What to do next
To discuss the adult treatment plan, ask for a conversation with the treating physician. Bring questions you've written. If you still don't understand an explanation, ask the physician to make it clearer. If you think a care decision harmed your family member, request a review of the case instead of judging the adult’s care by advice about birth injury.
Common questions
Is adult HIE treated the same way as newborn HIE?
Does an adult with HIE need cooling therapy?
Does HIE always cause permanent disability?
Sources
- Hypoxic-ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE), Cerebral Palsy Lawyer
- Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE): An Evolving ..., NICU Learning Nest
- Discussion of severe anoxic brain injury, Reddit, r/TBI


