Skip to content
Malpractice Center

What Are the Odds of Winning a Wrongful Death Lawsuit?

Your chances aren't something a settlement figure reveals. Before a lawyer can assess your family's case, they need to review the evidence and the rules where you'd file.

Sources checked

An older couple sitting on a bench in a hospital garden
On this page(5)

Without reviewing your family's case, we can't responsibly give you a percentage chance of winning a wrongful death lawsuit. That requires reviewing your family's case. Be cautious if someone predicts a result before reviewing the facts, because a lawyer in your state or province needs that review to give a meaningful opinion.

The evidence comes first. Butler Prather's discussion of wrongful death settlements identifies the degree of negligence or misconduct as a major factor in calculating a settlement. River Run Law says there's no true average settlement amount: the circumstances of the death and the surviving family's losses affect the amount.

Because those details matter, a headline payout can't predict your family's result. You can't establish a success rate from either point.

Separate the chance of winning from the possible payout

When you say “odds,” explain what you mean. Do you mean reaching a settlement, or are you asking about winning at trial? Keep the possible amount a separate question. Because a dollar figure doesn't show how likely either outcome is, ask about the amount on its own.

According to Grey Law's settlement guide, you could receive more at a successful trial than through a settlement. Far less is possible, too. Winning the case doesn't settle the question of its worth, even when the result goes your way.

Three questions to keep separate during a case review
QuestionWhat to ask the lawyer
How strong is the case?What evidence supports your assessment, and what remains uncertain?
What might a settlement be worth?How do the circumstances of the death and our family's losses affect your estimate?
Should we accept a settlement or consider trial?How should we weigh the proposed amount against the possibility of a higher or lower trial result?
Questions about your own case?

Ask for reasons, rather than a confidence score

Try asking “What makes you think this case is strong or weak?” rather than “What percentage chance do we have?” Have the lawyer connect their reasons to the evidence in your case. If someone makes a broad statement about wrongful death cases, they haven't assessed your family's facts.

Ask which parts of the chart the lawyer needs to review if you believe medical care caused the death. Before they give you an informed opinion, find out what further assessment they'll need to make. Even when an early conversation sounds encouraging, you shouldn't take it as a final prediction.

If your US claim concerns medical care, start with the medical malpractice page or the wrongful death page. Keep your family's facts in focus when you speak with a lawyer. Someone else's result isn't a basis for asking them to put a percentage on your case.

There isn't a true average settlement to work backward from

There's no true average wrongful death settlement, according to River Run Law's explanation, which rejects that idea. What the case is worth depends on how the death happened and what losses the surviving family members suffered.

Use the same caution when reading a firm's published result. Although the amount shows what happened in that case, you can't tell from it how closely those facts match yours. Nor can you use it to tell how likely your family is to obtain a similar result.

Ask what supports the figure when a lawyer discusses a possible settlement amount with you. Keep fees and case expenses separate from that question, asking how they'd affect the money available to your family and requesting an explanation in writing. What you're quoted isn't necessarily what you'll take home.

Get an assessment under your local rules

Which wrongful death rules apply depends on your state or province. If your claim is Canadian, a US firm's discussion can't replace advice about it; Texas rules on a page don't establish the rules elsewhere. Have a lawyer where you'd file the case explain what those rules mean for your family's claim.

To get started, use the US state pages or Canadian province pages. When you have a consultation, ask who can bring the claim and which statute of limitations applies. A general article isn't something to rely on when choosing your filing date.

What to do next

Have a lawyer review the case. Before the review, find out which records to bring and write down the events that concern you, along with the questions you most need answered. If something's uncertain, ask the lawyer what it is and what would help clear it up.

Treat this as general information, not legal advice. Talk with a lawyer in your state or province about your family's circumstances before deciding whether to pursue a claim or accept an offer.

Common questions

Is there a reliable percentage for winning a wrongful death lawsuit?
Giving your family's case a percentage isn't something we can responsibly do. Before explaining why they assess your case a certain way, a lawyer in your state or province needs to review the facts. Because reaching a settlement isn't the same as winning at trial, ask separately about the chance of each in your family's case. Keep the possible amount separate when you discuss it.
How much does a wrongful death lawsuit pay?
There's no true average wrongful death settlement, according to River Run Law. What matters is how the death happened and what losses the surviving family members suffered. Instead of reading a published payout as a prediction of what your case might produce, ask a lawyer how those factors affect the case your family would bring.
Could a trial award be lower than a settlement offer?
Yes. Even if a trial succeeds, it could produce far less than the settlement amount, as Grey Law's wrongful death settlement guide explains. Although a trial could produce more, the possibility of a larger award doesn't promise you'll get a larger result. When reviewing an offer, have your lawyer discuss that uncertainty with you.
How much of a settlement would my family keep?
What your family would keep may differ from the stated settlement amount. You can't calculate what you'd take home from a settlement figure alone. Ask your lawyer to explain fees and case expenses in writing before you accept an offer, including how those costs would affect the proposed payment.

Sources

  1. How to Calculate a Wrongful Death Settlement, Grey Law
  2. What Is the Average Settlement Amount for Wrongful Death Cases?, River Run Law
  3. How Are Wrongful Death Settlements Calculated?, Butler Prather

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.