Skip to content
Malpractice Center

How is hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) diagnosed?

You can't get HIE diagnostic criteria from parents' stories. When your baby's treating clinician explains the diagnosis, ask to see the chart.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(4)

You can't use parents' Reddit accounts to establish diagnostic criteria for hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE). As your baby's treating clinician goes through the chart, ask how it supports the diagnosis under the clinical guidance they're using. This page doesn't offer a diagnostic checklist that's been medically verified.

You need to understand what they're explaining. Have the clinician go through the HIE entry in your baby's chart so you understand what it says. Another family's story shouldn't be what you rely on to make sense of that entry.

Ask what supports the diagnosis in your baby's chart

Read the chart's wording as written. When you ask about the diagnosis, find out whether the clinician has confirmed it. Ask about further evaluation if the note mentions a concern. Have them explain any abbreviation you don't recognize.

When you review that chart wording, ask which findings prompted it. Have the clinician explain. If you're checking your baby's records against a discussion forum checklist, ask the clinician why the diagnosis fits; the checklist can't tell you.

Questions to take to the care team
  1. Identify the guidance

    One question to ask is: “Which clinical guideline or diagnostic framework are you using for HIE?” Ask for its name or an accessible link so you can look it up.

  2. Connect the criteria to the record

    When the clinician explains the diagnosis, can they point to the chart entries or test reports they're using? What does each finding mean for your baby?

  3. Clarify what remains uncertain

    If the team is waiting for results, ask whether those could change how they've worded the diagnosis. Have them explain what they've established. You can ask for an explanation without medical jargon.

  4. Write down the next step

    Who can you contact with follow-up questions, and when should you expect another conversation? Don't leave without asking. Keep the notes from that conversation alongside the questions you've written down.

Questions about your own case?

Don't use another baby's story as a diagnostic rule

In a Reddit discussion about a family's HIE experience, one commenter's account includes an induced delivery and shoulder dystocia. Although they're describing what happened to them, that account isn't a clinical guideline for diagnosing HIE.

A parent comments on an MRI and their child's later development in another NICUParents discussion. Those comments can't tell you how to interpret your own baby's scan medically.

A story may help you figure out what to ask. Try asking this: “I read a parent's account about an MRI. Can you explain what my baby's report says and what conclusions you draw from it?”

Keep the diagnosis and concerns about care separate

Before you ask about the care, write down the particular event involving your baby that worries you. Have the care team explain wording you don't understand as you go through the relevant chart entry or delivery note together.

If you'd like those concerns reviewed legally, you can ask a lawyer in your state or province. What do those legal rules mean for you? Ask. The US HIE malpractice page is another page you can visit. You're reading general information here, not legal advice.

What to do next

Arrange a conversation to ask about the diagnosis. Bring the chart's exact wording so the clinician can explain which findings led them to write it. Keep your questions about the care with the records you plan to bring to a lawyer if you also want that lawyer to review it.

Common questions

Where should I look for HIE diagnostic criteria?
To find out which clinical guideline or diagnostic framework is being used, ask your baby's treating clinician. How does that guideline apply to the findings recorded in your baby's chart? Have them explain. Although the linked NICUParents discussions describe parents' experiences, they don't provide a medically verified set of diagnostic criteria.
Can I use a parent's MRI comments to understand my baby's diagnosis?
You can't understand your baby's MRI by relying on a Reddit comment. Ask what your baby's treating clinician concludes from the actual report while you're going over it together. Write down a question about another parent's comment if it worries you; that comment isn't a finding about what happened to your child.
What should I ask if the diagnosis is unclear?
Is HIE confirmed, or does the team still see it as a possibility? Where in the chart can they show you why? Is there information the team is still waiting for? Find out. Keep a note of terms you want clarified next time you talk, as you listen to the clinician's plain-language explanation.

Sources

  1. NICUParents discussion: Our HIE experience, Reddit, r/NICUParents
  2. NICUParents discussion: UK-based HIE experience, Reddit, r/NICUParents

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.