Skip to content
Malpractice Center

Premature Delivery and Suspected Negligence: What Can You Do?

Let your questions about the care you received guide you. To understand how to assess those concerns, talk with a lawyer in your state or province.

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(4)

Ask a lawyer in your state or province to review what happened if you believe medical negligence caused a premature delivery. First, write it down. When you ask how to get the relevant medical records, treat negligence as something to investigate, not something the early delivery alone lets you conclude.

Your explanation doesn't have to be finished. You can simply say, “I don't understand why delivery happened when it did, and I want someone to look at the care.” Ask someone you trust to help organize your questions if you're also grieving.

Separate what happened from what you suspect

What you remember comes first. After describing the symptoms you reported and who you spoke with, write down what you remember being told. Point out any uncertainty. Rather than fill in a date you don't remember, say “I think this happened before admission” (that's more useful).

Keep your concerns about decisions separate from what you observed. An event is described by “I reported cramping”. A medical review can address the question raised by “The cramping should have prompted a different response”. When you bring up both, you don't have to treat the second as a fact that's already established.

Which decision do you want explained? If a phone call or hospital assessment concerns you, the response to it may be what you want explained. Delivery's timing may be the concern. To identify the part of your care that troubles you, you don't need to have the medical answer yet.

Prepare for an initial conversation
  1. Write a short account

    Begin your account with the first concerning event, ending with delivery. When you know dates, include them; mark gaps rather than guess. Keep the wording yours.

  2. Gather what you already have

    Keep your discharge paperwork together with the messages about your care. To get other records, ask the lawyer which ones to request and how.

  3. List the unanswered questions

    Include why delivery happened when it did among the questions you write down. Before a medical reviewer draws a conclusion, what would they need to examine?

  4. Ask about local deadlines

    Tell the lawyer where the care happened and when. Which statute of limitations applies to your circumstances, and is there another deadline you need to address?

Questions about your own case?

Use online accounts for support, not a verdict

A commenter in a Reddit discussion about second-trimester miscarriage urged the person posting not to blame themselves after describing being told that cramping was normal. That experience may sound familiar. Even if it does, the account can't establish what happened in your pregnancy or whether your care was negligent.

Yours isn't explained by another family's experience. Write down a question for your clinician or lawyer if a post brings up a concern you hadn't thought about before. A stranger's conclusion about when delivery should have happened belongs apart from the question you want to ask.

Speaking with a lawyer was suggested by a commenter in Reddit's LegalAdviceIreland forum, who also mentioned an expert medical report. Because that informal advice concerned an Irish claim, it doesn't tell you what US or Canadian requirements are. To find out whether your situation would require an expert report, ask a lawyer where you live.

Ask who would examine the records and what costs you might have to pay before you agree to a review. The firm's proposed fee arrangement needs an explanation. If the review doesn't support a claim, what happens then?

What to do next

When you request a case review, provide a brief account with your main unanswered question. The obstetrical malpractice page has US practice-area information. Tell the lawyer where the care took place before you discuss the next step. You don't have to decide beforehand that someone was negligent to ask for an assessment.

Common questions

Does a premature delivery mean my doctor was negligent?
You can't judge your care by the timing of delivery alone. To learn what information is needed, ask a lawyer to explain and assess the decisions that concern you. You don't have to supply a medical conclusion, just stick to what happened. Whether negligence caused your delivery isn't something this page can determine.
What should I bring to a first conversation with a lawyer?
Whatever paperwork you already have should accompany your written account. When you add dates you remember, make clear where your memory is uncertain. Which medical records does the lawyer want to review? Before you request an initial assessment, you don't need to turn your account into a legal argument.
Will I need an expert medical report?
To find out whether you need a report, ask a lawyer in your state or province. If you do, who would prepare it, and how would you handle the cost? Although a Reddit comment about an Irish negligence claim mentions an expert report, it doesn't tell you what a US or Canadian case requires.
How long do I have to take legal action?
Which statute of limitations applies to your circumstances, and does another deadline need attention? Ask a local lawyer. If you're uncertain about dates, say so when you share the date and location of the care. You won't find a filing deadline for your case on this page. A deadline mentioned in someone else's online account isn't one you should rely on.

Sources

  1. Medical negligence claim discussion, Reddit, r/legaladviceireland
  2. Second-trimester miscarriage discussion, Reddit, r/Miscarriage

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.