Skip to content
Malpractice Center

When Is It Time for a Loved One to Move to a Nursing Home?

Before considering a move, compare your loved one's care needs with the help available at home. Could a nursing home provide the care they need instead?

Sources checked

A family talking quietly together in a hospital corridor
On this page(6)

If you can't reliably provide the care or supervision your loved one needs at home, consider a nursing home. Don't decide based on age alone. Consider their daily needs. According to Willows Healthcare, the main things to consider are a person's health and functional abilities, along with how much support they need.

Look at how things go at home. When you talk with your loved one's healthcare team, explain what help they need overnight, too. Could more home support meet those needs, or does the team recommend an assessment for nursing home care?

Signs that deserve a care assessment

According to Willows Healthcare, someone may need constant care if they're forgetful or confused or show behavioral changes such as aggression. If you notice these changes, ask for an assessment. A nursing home isn't necessarily the only option when these changes appear.

Frequent clinical treatments and heavy mechanical lifts may favor nursing home care, according to Powerpuff Shield's article on nursing home decisions. It also points to the need for constant wandering supervision. Ask prospective facilities exactly how they'd provide that help if your loved one needs it.

Turn concerns at home into questions for the care team
ConcernWhat to ask
Confusion or changes in behaviorDoes this mean my loved one needs constant supervision? What assessment would help us decide?
Wandering that requires constant supervisionCan our home care arrangement provide that supervision, including overnight?
Need for a mechanical liftWhat equipment and help are needed, and can they be provided at home?
Frequent clinical treatmentsWhich setting can provide these treatments consistently?

The team needs specifics. When you say, “Mom is getting worse,” explain the confusion you've seen or the supervision she needs now. Because stress can make it hard to remember, write down what you've noticed and bring it with you.

Look honestly at what the family can provide

Does the help that's actually available match your loved one's care needs? When you write down who provides care and when, make the gaps clear (especially at night). If no one has agreed to cover those gaps, don't count on promises.

You can't always provide constant care for someone you love. Tell the healthcare team plainly if the current arrangement only works when you're available every hour.

“When you are asking if it’s time, it’s time.” That's how an anonymous commenter in Reddit's dementia community put it. A worn-out caregiver may recognize that feeling in those words. But they don't assess your loved one's health, and feeling worried means you should ask for help, not automatically decide it's time to move.

Questions about your own case?

Compare nursing home care with the actual alternatives

Don't rely on a setting's label. When you speak with the healthcare team, compare nursing home care with assisted living or additional home support that might meet your loved one's current needs.

When you contact each facility, describe the help your loved one needs. How would staff provide constant wandering supervision during the night? Ask whether the facility can meet that need if your loved one requires a mechanical lift.

Before budgeting, get written costs and an explanation of the care they cover. Don't base your budget on a price or insurance claim you read in an online discussion. The facility and relevant payer can explain what applies, so ask about your loved one's circumstances.

Make room for your loved one's voice

When possible, your loved one should join the discussion. What worries them about moving, and what parts of life at home would they like to keep? When you speak with prospective facilities, tell them about those preferences.

When describing the care problem, don't make the person sound like a burden. Everyone has something concrete to discuss when you say, “We need help providing care overnight”. Rather than arguing over whether a move means the family has failed, ask relatives to discuss that need.

You can't judge care needs by feeling guilty. When the discussion drifts, return to what your loved one needs and who can help.

Plan how you'll stay involved after a move

Find out before admission who handles your care concerns and what the facility does when a resident starts needing different help. You and your loved one should discuss visits. How do staff suggest you help them adjust?

Keep written notes of what worries you and how people respond. Although your loved one will receive care somewhere different after moving, you should still ask questions.

What to do next

Ask for a care assessment. When you bring your written account of daily life at home, ask what the team recommends for your loved one's needs. Can each proposed care setting actually provide the care described in that recommendation?

You can explore long-term care negligence if you're worried that existing facility care may be causing harm. This gives general information, not legal advice. Because the rules differ by state and province, ask a lawyer where your loved one receives care how those rules apply.

Common questions

Does confusion mean my parent needs a nursing home?
That alone isn't enough. According to Willows Healthcare, someone who's confused or shows behavioral changes may need constant care. Before deciding to move, describe the changes to their healthcare team and ask what assessment they need, because the right setting still depends on the person's needs and the help available.
How can I deal with guilt about moving a parent into care?
When deciding what to do, set guilt apart. Once you've written down your parent's care needs and the help you can actually provide, discuss any gaps with their healthcare team. Ask how visits and conversations about care can keep you involved if the team recommends a move. You can still play a role after placement.
How can I help someone adjust to a nursing home?
When your loved one tells you what worries them, talk about it and let staff know. While discussing visits, ask who you should contact about care concerns. Can the facility provide an adjustment plan suited to your loved one? Another family's experience can't tell you how yours will handle the move, so don't assume it will.

Sources

  1. How to Determine if Your Parent Needs a Nursing Home, Willows Healthcare
  2. How to Know When a Loved One Needs Long-Term Care, Willows Healthcare
  3. Recognizing When an Aging Parent Needs a Nursing Home, Powerpuff Shield
  4. Family discussion about when to consider care for a parent with dementia, Reddit, r/dementia

Related guides

Tell us what happened. We'll help you find out if you have a case.

Most people who reach out aren't sure yet, and that's fine. Share a few lines and a malpractice lawyer near you can look at it with you, at no cost.

  • It's free, and talking to a lawyer doesn't commit you to anything.
  • Where we know the local rules, you'll see your likely filing deadline right away.
  • Your answers are encrypted and never sold or used for ads.

Start with one question

Hurt by medical care?Talk it through with a lawyer, free.