Best Medical Malpractice Lawyers in Indiana (2026)
The malpractice lawyers in Indiana we'd call first, drawn from every city list we've published in the state. Each one takes medical malpractice cases, and you can reach them right here.
Of the 8 firms on our 1 city list in Indiana, Garau Germano, P.C. scores highest on malpractice focus, published results, client reviews and experience, followed by Woody & Vaughan, P.C. and Hensley Legal Group, PC. Each firm keeps its best score from the cities it serves; open a city for its full list.
According to Garau Germano, P.C.'s own site, Shan Bryant-Haase obtained a $1.675 million settlement in 2024 for a family whose child died soon after birth. For a failure to diagnose colon cancer, the firm publishes a $2.5 million verdict.
We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made
We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made
In repeated reviews, clients credit Hensley Legal Group, PC with explaining the process clearly and keeping them informed. On Google, the firm's listing shows 4,010 reviews and a 4.9 rating.
We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made
CohenMalad, LLP's site addresses dental malpractice as well as birth injury. That distinction can help if your concern involves dental treatment rather than hospital care. Gregory L.
We order firms by how much of their work is medical malpractice, the results they publish, what their clients say, their experience, their standing with the regulator and the recognition they have earned, all from public records and the firms' own sites. How lists are made
Full Indiana law guidedeadlines, caps, children, experts and sources
Example: treatment and discovery six months ago
Today
TreatmentMay 21, 2026
Likely deadlineMay 21, 2028
The filing deadline in Indiana
The clock startsOn the day of the treatment
Time to start a claim2 yearsMiss it and the claim is usually lost.
The rules in Indiana
Filing deadline
2 years
Counted from the treatment. File (with the Indiana Department of Insurance, to start the medical review panel) within 2 years of the act, omission or neglect.
Limited. Courts allow 2 years from discovery when the patient could not reasonably have discovered the malpractice within the 2-year period, to avoid an unconstitutional result.
Outer limit
None found
We found no statute of repose for Indiana.
Damage caps
Indiana caps all damages, not just non-economic, for claims against providers qualified under the Medical Malpractice Act. The Indiana courts have upheld the cap.
Total
$1,800,000 total for all damages for acts on or after July 1, 2019 ($1,650,000 for July 2017 to June 2019); a qualified provider pays at most $500,000 and the Patient's Compensation Fund pays the rest.
A child under 6 has until the eighth birthday. Older children are held to the same 2-year rule as adults.
Affidavit of merit
Not required
No affidavit of merit; the medical review panel takes its place.
Notice before suing
Required
A proposed complaint must be filed with the Indiana Department of Insurance and reviewed by a medical review panel before suit, unless the parties agree to skip it or the claim is for $15,000 or less. The deadline is suspended during review; sue within 90 days after the panel's opinion.
Ind. Code §§ 34-18-8-4, 34-18-7-3
Shared fault
Contributory
Contributory negligence: any fault of yours can bar recovery
Experts
Expert evidence
The panel's opinion is admissible at trial; expert testimony is generally required to prove the standard of care.
Indiana's Comparative Fault Act does not apply to medical malpractice, so contributory negligence remains a complete defense (Cavens v. Zaberdac, Indiana Supreme Court, 2006). Attorney fees paid from the Patient's Compensation Fund are limited to 32 percent for acts after June 30, 2017. These rules apply to providers qualified under the Act.
If your provider is qualified under Indiana's Medical Malpractice Act, you generally have two years from the act, omission or neglect to file your proposed complaint with the Indiana Department of Insurance.
Filing starts the process of medical review by a panel. Indiana caps damages in these claims, but a patient's own negligence can mean there's no recovery at all. Before deciding whether to proceed, have an Indiana lawyer look at your treatment dates and check whether your provider is qualified under the Act.
This guide isn't legal advice; it gives general information. An Indiana lawyer can explain what these rules mean for the treatment you received or your child's injury.
The deadline starts with the treatment, usually
The alleged act, omission or neglect starts the ordinary filing period under Indiana Code § 34-18-7-1(b). Learning that something went wrong doesn't automatically start the filing clock. If you discover the problem later, the time between those dates can make a big difference.
Filing deadlines in Indiana
The injury
The clock usually starts on the date of the malpractice or injury.
Discovery
Limited. Courts allow 2 years from discovery when the patient could not reasonably have discovered the malpractice within the 2-year period, to avoid an unconstitutional result.
2 years
File (with the Indiana Department of Insurance, to start the medical review panel) within 2 years of the act, omission or neglect. (Ind. Code § 34-18-7-1(b))
Children
A child under 6 has until the eighth birthday. Older children are held to the same 2-year rule as adults.
Late discovery has a limited exception
Indiana courts allow two years from discovery to avoid an unconstitutional result if the patient couldn't reasonably have discovered the malpractice within the original two-year period. It's a limited exception. You may question your treatment later, but that or a delayed diagnosis doesn't automatically give you more time.
Give a lawyer your treatment dates to compare with the date you first learned of possible malpractice. Bring your chart if you've got it. The law won't necessarily use the day someone explained the problem to you as the date you discovered the malpractice.
Children and any outer deadline
A child under six has until the eighth birthday to file, but older children must follow the two-year rule adults face. Some minors don't get extra time. Your lawyer will need your child's birth date, as well as the treatment dates, for a claim about their care.
Your claim may have a separate outer limit (sometimes called a statute of repose); ask an Indiana lawyer to check. Have the lawyer check whether a discovery exception applies, too.
When you claim against qualified providers, Indiana's cap covers all damages, not just non-economic damages. The courts have upheld the cap, with its limits set by Indiana Code § 34-18-14-3.
Indiana caps all damages, not just non-economic, for claims against providers qualified under the Medical Malpractice Act. The Indiana courts have upheld the cap.
Damages
Limit in Indiana
Total damages
$1,800,000 total for all damages for acts on or after July 1, 2019 ($1,650,000 for July 2017 to June 2019); a qualified provider pays at most $500,000 and the Patient's Compensation Fund pays the rest.
The total limit has changed over time, so check when the alleged malpractice happened. The law splits the payment, with the qualified provider paying part and the Patient's Compensation Fund paying part. Neither one promises that your claim will be paid.
The cap doesn't tell you what your case is worth. Ask counsel how the limit affects the claim you're considering and what the Fund's role would be. Any separate rules for punitive damages or wrongful death, and whether a separate non-economic limit applies, need checking with a local lawyer.
Keep the fee discussion separate. Attorney fees paid from the Patient's Compensation Fund are limited to 32 percent when the acts occurred after June 30, 2017. Before you sign the proposed fee agreement, have your lawyer explain its terms, including that restriction.
What a claim needs before court
Indiana requires a medical review panel rather than an affidavit of merit. You'll usually start a claim covered by the Act by filing a proposed complaint with the Indiana Department of Insurance. The panel reviews the claim before you sue in court.
What a claim needs in Indiana
Requirement
The rule
Affidavit or certificate of merit
No affidavit of merit; the medical review panel takes its place.
Notice before suing
A proposed complaint must be filed with the Indiana Department of Insurance and reviewed by a medical review panel before suit, unless the parties agree to skip it or the claim is for $15,000 or less. The deadline is suspended during review; sue within 90 days after the panel's opinion.
Expert evidence
The panel's opinion is admissible at trial; expert testimony is generally required to prove the standard of care.
Shared fault rule
Contributory negligence
The parties can skip panel review if they agree. Claims of $15,000 or less don't require panel review at all. Filing with the Department of Insurance isn't the same as filing a court complaint, so ask your lawyer whether an exception covers your claim before you choose where to file.
The panel doesn't replace trial testimony
The panel's opinion can be admitted at trial. Proving the standard of care generally takes expert testimony, even with that opinion. You'll usually still need medical testimony to pursue your claim, even though Indiana doesn't require an affidavit.
Ask the lawyer at your first consultation what medical review they'd need to judge the care you received. That's not something you have to work out yourself. Your lawyer can also explain how they'd use your chart and the panel opinion in pursuing your claim.
Shared fault can defeat a claim
Medical malpractice claims covered by these rules aren't subject to Indiana's Comparative Fault Act. Contributory negligence is still a complete defense, an issue the Indiana Supreme Court addressed in Cavens v. Zaberdac.
This rule goes beyond taking a percentage off your damages. If anyone disputes what you did during treatment, tell your lawyer what happened, including the instructions you received. Your lawyer must decide whether what happened counts as contributory negligence under the law, not just fault during treatment.
How a case usually proceeds
From consultation to a possible settlement or trial
1
Check the filing route and deadline
At the first consultation, explain when you learned of the possible problem and give the lawyer your treatment dates. Ask which filing deadline applies to you, with the lawyer checking whether your provider is qualified under the Act.
2
Assess the medical support
Talk about whether the records show care met the standard. Proving your claim generally takes expert testimony, so ask what medical assessment you'd need before deciding whether to pursue it.
3
File the proposed complaint
If your claim needs panel review, you'll have to meet the deadline for filing with the Indiana Department of Insurance. Don't rely on an exception until your lawyer checks whether it covers your claim.
4
Go through medical review
The medical review panel gives its opinion once it's considered your claim. The filing clock stops while review is underway. The panel's opinion brings another deadline; ask your lawyer to keep track of it.
5
Proceed to court if the claim continues
If you decide to continue, keep track of the deadline to file in court after the panel's opinion. You'll generally need expert testimony to prove the standard of care at trial, even though the panel opinion is admissible.
6
Discuss settlement or trial
Talk through what a trial would involve, including whether you could settle. Neither the panel process nor the damages cap promises you'll get paid. Before accepting a proposed resolution, have your lawyer explain what the cap would mean for it, including any payment from the Fund.
What you can do now
Write down a brief timeline. For a claim about your child's care, note their birth date and list when treatment happened beside the date you first suspected a problem.
Pull together the records you already have about your concern, including any chart or delivery notes that relate to it.
Put what you'd like the lawyer to assess in writing. Keep your recollections apart from the medical record when you write them down.
Don't wait to ask for a deadline review if it's been nearly two years since you received the treatment.
Before agreeing to pursue the claim, talk about fees, including how the damages cap could affect your claim.
Whether the care was malpractice isn't something you have to decide for yourself. At a consultation, ask whether you still have time to file and talk through the medical evidence that might support your claim. Bring your dates, even if some records are still missing.
AllLaw's Indiana Medical Malpractice Laws and Statutory Rules gives an overview if you'd like to read about the statutes cited here. An Indiana lawyer can explain which rules apply to your treatment if you found the problem late or don't know whether the provider is qualified.
How long do I have to sue for medical malpractice in Indiana?
The usual two years starts with the act, omission or neglect. If medical review is required, you first file a proposed complaint with the Indiana Department of Insurance, rather than in court. A limited discovery exception may apply, apart from the different rule for young children. Ask an Indiana lawyer to work out your claim's deadline; don't count only from the day you learned something went wrong.
What is considered medical malpractice in Indiana?
A lawyer assessing your claim must look at whether the care met the standard, something you generally need expert testimony to prove. You'll ordinarily go through a medical review panel before suing a qualified provider in Indiana, unless an exception applies. The opinion can be admitted at trial. An Indiana lawyer can look through your records and explain whether there's support for a malpractice claim based on your care.
Is it worth suing for medical malpractice in Indiana?
Your situation determines whether it's worth suing. Your claim can fail entirely because of contributory negligence; claims against qualified providers also face Indiana's limit on total damages. You'll generally need expert testimony that establishes what the standard of care required. Ask your lawyer what medical evidence supports your claim, along with how the cap might limit any damages. Review what you'd pay in fees, too. A panel opinion or damages limit doesn't mean you'll recover money.
Does Indiana have a cap on medical malpractice damages?
Yes. All damages fall under Indiana's cap for qualified providers, not just non-economic damages. The total limit is $1,800,000 if the acts occurred on or after July 1, 2019. A qualified provider pays no more than $500,000, with the Patient's Compensation Fund paying the rest. Have an Indiana lawyer check which limit applies to your treatment date, because earlier acts can fall under a different limit.
Do malpractice claims have a statute of limitations?
Yes. Indiana's ordinary medical malpractice statute of limitations runs from the act, omission or neglect, not automatically from when you discover the problem. Courts allow a limited discovery exception to avoid an unconstitutional result when the patient couldn't reasonably have discovered the malpractice during the original period. Your claim might also have a separate outer deadline, so have an Indiana lawyer check.
Does my child have more time to file an Indiana malpractice claim?
A child under six can file up until their eighth birthday. Don't assume your child's claim can wait until adulthood, because older children face the same two-year rule as adults. Give an Indiana lawyer the dates of treatment and your child's birth date. The lawyer can also check whether discovering the problem later affects your claim's filing deadline.
Do I need an affidavit of merit before filing in Indiana?
No. You'll go through a medical review panel in Indiana rather than submit an affidavit of merit. You'll generally need to file a proposed complaint with the Indiana Department of Insurance for panel review before you can sue in court. The parties can agree to skip review, which isn't required at all for claims of $15,000 or less. Proving the standard of care still generally calls for expert testimony, despite the panel review. At trial, the panel opinion is admissible.